Showing posts with label good writing. Show all posts
Showing posts with label good writing. Show all posts

22 November 2026

The First Page


 "It is difficult to know quite where to begin this story…"

Whether you're writing a short story or a novel, every work of fiction begins in the same place: page one. And before readers can get caught up in your plot twists and fall in love with your characters, they make a judgement. The first page is your story's first impression.

When you meet someone for the first time, within seconds of talking, you form an opinion. You notice a person's appearance, confidence, manner, and voice, with your opinion hitting somewhere between this person is a bore and I'm in love. The impressions you draw may not always be accurate, but they influence whether you want to continue the conversation.

Readers do the same thing with fiction.

From the first few paragraphs, they ask questions, mostly unconsciously. Is this a story I want to spend time with? Am I intrigued? Does this writer know what they're doing? Am I in safe hands?

A strong first page builds trust between writer and reader. It signals confidence, establishes the kind of story being told, and creates enough curiosity to encourage the reader to keep turning pages. A weak first page can have the opposite effect, causing readers to put the book back on the shelf or skip to the next story in the magazine or anthology – if it makes it into print at all.

So, May We Start?

Many writers obsess over opening lines and clever hooks, and they overlook the special task of the first page: it's a doorway. The reader arrives, carrying the distractions, worries, and routines of their day, and your first page leads them into another world. It's the transition point between their reality and your story.

The opening page doesn't need to contain explosions, shocking revelations, or life-or-death stakes – these are gimmick openings. What it must do is invite the reader into your story's world and make them want to stay there. 

The most important thing a first page should do is start the story. Obvious, yes? But many authors delay the story. They open with exposition, backstory, or world-building. None of these is a story. Readers pick up fiction because they want to experience events unfolding, so get on with it. Start where something is happening, where something matters… to someone.

A strong first page usually centres on a character, ideally the main character. Readers need someone to attach themselves to as quickly as possible. Start with something important to this character and their journey. And we should see who this person is through action rather than description (we don't need to know their haircut or eye colour (not yet anyway)). What are they doing? What do they want? What is important to them in this moment? And we should begin to feel something for them. Curiosity. Sympathy. Admiration. Concern. Amusement, even. The emotional connection does not have to be deep, but it should begin as soon as possible.

Dialogue can be a powerful tool in an opening, and if your protagonist speaks on the first page, that first line is worth thinking about. Often, a character's first line of dialogue can echo through the entire story. It may reveal their worldview, establish a central conflict, hint at their deepest desire, or foreshadow what is to come. Readers may not consciously notice its importance on first reading, but memorable openings often contain this kind of resonance.

The first page should also establish orientation. Readers need to know where they are, and roughly when they are. This does not require paragraphs of description. A few carefully chosen details can quickly anchor the setting/location and time period.

Clarity matters on the first page. Confused readers are rarely intrigued readers. Confusion is a roadblock. Mystery is good; disorientation is not. Readers should grasp the basics of the situation before the first page has ended.  

Curiosity is one of the most powerful forces in storytelling, and a great way to start a story is to put a question or two in the reader's mind. Why is this character doing this? What is about to happen? Why is this situation unusual? Why is everyone staring at the flight arrivals board with sad faces? Why is the schoolteacher's desk on fire? Why is the small boy holding a BB gun and looking guilty?

Conflict, tension, or uncertainty should also be present from the start. This doesn't mean explosions, gunfights, or someone hanging from a cliff edge. In fact, blatant dramatic hooks are surprisingly weak because they lack context. There's no build up. If a stranger is dangling from a cliff on page one, readers may recognise the danger, but they don't yet care about the person. There are no emotional stakes. Real engagement comes from investment in character and situation. A woman quietly burning an important document can be more compelling than a car chase if the reader senses the act matters.

The first page should give readers a sense of what kind of story they have picked up. Is this crime, mystery, romance, fantasy, horror, literary, something else? The tone, mood, and voice should signal the sort of journey ahead. Readers like to know what promises the story is making. Foreshadowing can help achieve this. Small hints, suggestions, warnings, and echoes of future events create the feeling that something significant is brewing beneath the surface. The reader should sense movement, even if they can't yet see the destination.

Point of view is equally important. Write with a clear perspective and remain consistent in your person: first, second (please, no), third (limited, omniscient, objective). Readers should understand whose story they are experiencing and through whose eyes they are seeing the world.

Above all, write with confidence. The first page is where readers decide whether they trust you. A clear, assured voice tells readers that the story is in capable hands. 

By the end of the first page, the reader should know where they are, who they are with, and have a strong sense that something important is underway. They should be curious, oriented, and emotionally connected enough to turn the page… because they want to know what happens next.


Some Don'ts

  • Don't begin with a dream sequence. Readers dislike discovering that the scene they invested in was not really happening.
  • Don't begin with someone waking up, making breakfast, or making a cup of tea unless the moment is genuinely meaningful. If it's Bob's first morning in prison and he's an innocent man, that's a story. If Agatha is poisoning the vicar's tea, that's a story. Ordinary daily routines without significance seldom make for compelling fiction.
  • Don't confuse activity with engagement. Readers are not hooked because something dramatic is happening. They are hooked because something meaningful is happening.

Some Great Opening Sentences

"The same week our fowls were stolen, Daphne Moran had her throat cut."
            The Scarecrow by Ronald Hugh Morrieson (1963)

"Jack Torrance thought: Officious little prick."
            The Shining by Stephen King (1977)

"Ten days after the war ended, my sister Laura drove a car off a bridge. "
            The Blind Assassin by Margaret Atwood (2000),

"One morning, when Gregor Samsa woke from troubled dreams, he found himself transformed in his bed into a horrible vermin."
            Metamorphosis by Franz Kafka (1925)

"It is cold at six-forty in the morning on a March day in Paris, and seems even colder when a man is about to be executed by firing squad."
            The Day of the Jackel by Frederick Forsyth (1971)

“It is difficult to know quite where to begin this story, but I have fixed my choice on a certain Wednesday at luncheon at the Vicarage.”
            The Murder at the Vicarage by Agatha Christie (1930)



So, what is your favourite opening to one of your stories...? Tell us.



P.S. I learned on Friday that my book, THE BRIDE MUST BE STOPPED! (the first book in my Mean City Mysteries) is a finalist for the 2026 Ngaio Marsh Award - Best Kids-YA Novel. Yup, I'm pretty excited! (The Ngaio Marsh Awards are the New Zealand equivalent to the Edgar Awards.)  😀







© 2026 Stephen Ross

www.StephenRoss.net

www.Mean.City


23 August 2026

On-The-Nose Dialogue


One of the most iconic lines of dialogue in movies is from Jaws, 1975.

"You're gonna need a bigger boat."

Sheriff Brody's retort reveals his sense of humour in the face of terror, and his understatement as to the size of their adversary. Brody isn't literally suggesting they head back to shore and procure a larger vessel.

"That's a big shark. We're going to have a lot of trouble catching that."

Had Brody said this line of on-the-nose dialogue instead, the scene would have had no spark, nothing about his character would have been revealed, and people certainly wouldn't be quoting it half a century later.

Why is that line on-the nose?

Because it's too literal, too explicit. It's so direct and free of ambiguity or subtext, stating exactly what the character is thinking, that the character may as well be a robot.

Etymology: The expression "on-the-nose" originated at the track in the early 20th century. Bettors would wager “on the nose,” meaning on a horse to win outright, not place or show. This usage meant directly, exactly, no hedging.

Dialogue is the fuel that runs a story. It moves the story forward, reveals character, delivers information, and gives a story its identity. Think of movies like All About Eve, written by Joseph Mankiewicz, or Pulp Fiction, written by Quentin Tarantino, or books like The Big Sleep and Farewell, My Lovely, written by Raymond Chandler. The dialogue in these works has a certain flavour and sparkle that is distinctive and memorable – goals for any writer.

At the other end of the scale is on-the-nose dialogue. It has no sparkle or uniqueness. It states literally what a character thinks, feels, or intends, with zero subtext, tension, or ambiguity. It's the weakest form of dialogue because there is nothing for the reader to infer or learn about the character saying it.

On-the-nose dialogue:

Tells instead of shows

"I'm angry."

Names emotions instead of dramatising them

“I’m so happy you are my friend”

Explains motives instead of revealing them

“I don’t love him anymore.”

Removes tension by stating the truth directly

“I did not hit her. I did not!”

Feels like the writer speaking, not the character

"This is about building trust."

The failure of on-the-nose dialogue is its lack of dramatic subtlety. It's artificial. People don't talk like that in real life. And when they do in movies or books, they are merely "devices" for the author to convey information or exposition, not three-dimensional characters with which we want to invest our time and interest.

Real people almost never articulate their emotions, especially when they’re hurt or under pressure. They dodge, joke, stall, contradict themselves, or circle the truth without touching it. So, when a character says, “I’m angry because you betrayed me,” the line may be factually correct, but it lands flat. The audience already feels the anger from the situation; saying it out loud drains the moment of tension and robs the scene of its dramatic charge.

Three ways you can avoid on-the-nose dialogue:

  • Subtext
  • Behaviour instead of explanation
  • Misdirection

Subtext is the invisible layer beneath what's said and what's meant. It's the emotional or psychological truth that characters don’t say outright. Write about what the character wants in the moment, not what they feel. A character who wants reassurance might say, “Are you coming home tonight?” instead of “I’m afraid you’re pulling away from me.” The first line carries need, insecurity, and tension in its unspoken subtext. It lets the audience do the interpretive work.

Behaviour instead of explanation. Let your characters reveal emotion through actions like hesitation, interruption, sarcasm, and silence, rather than expressing that emotion directly. A snarky "Whatever" can communicate someone's hurt more effectively than a paragraph about feeling dismissed. Two characters arguing about what movie to go and see may actually be arguing about trust or resentment.

Misdirection. Let your characters talk about something trivial and mundane when something important is at stake. This creates tension and realism. Remember that scene in Pulp Fiction (Royale with cheese) where hitmen Vincent Vega and Jules Winnfield are driving to confront a group of young men in an apartment? They don't talk about the violence they're going to unleash; they talk about hash smoking, hamburgers, and putting mayonnaise on French fries. This is just another day at the office for these two. Killing people is no big deal.

On-the-nose dialogue is fine in the first draft. The writer is still discovering the emotional architecture of the scene, and once the structure is understood, the writer can return to the dialogue and replace literal statements with gestures, contradictions, or lines that reveal character through voice rather than exposition. Remember the golden rule: The key to writing is rewriting.

The real key to avoiding on‑the‑nose dialogue is trusting the reader. Drama lives in the space between what’s spoken and what’s actually meant. Give your dialogue moments of silence, suggestion, and ambiguity. That space – the part the reader fills in themselves – is where your story comes alive.

04 December 2016

Writing the Obvious


by Leigh Lundin

What makes a good writer?
He English good.


We take for granted our favorite authors are good writers. Like a talented musician, an Olympian gymnast, or an Oscar-winning actor, they entertain us on a professional level. We might not always experience a virtuoso performance, but we’re satisfied if we receive our money’s worth.

A few decades ago, I got to know workers in a factory. A supervisor– a portly, prejudiced and petty little man, lucky to have a job at all– complained about managing Portuguese women. Mr Eddy infamously said, “Their English, they don’t speak good.” In office jokes, that morphed into “They don’t English good.” He of the immense girth never understood the giggles behind his back nor grasped the fact the Portuguese senhoras had him well in hand. When the ladies answered the phone, the conversation went like this:
“Is Mr. Eddy ’round?”
“He shore is.”

Of course the man was complaining about the accent while failing technically correct English himself. Both are among the standards by which we judge people’s ability to communicate.

Regarding pastiches, I tend toward a dour viewpoint. Few authors who attempt take-offs of Sherlock Holmes and other great characters reach the high bar in my mind. There are exceptions including Dale Andrews and James Lincoln Warren.

Last month, I read David Lagercrantz’s The Girl in the Spider's Web, a follow-up to Stieg Larsson’s The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo. Lagercrantz’s version was… adequate. I couldn’t lay down Larsson’s novels, but while Lagercrantz’s effort was moderately entertaining, it wasn’t unputdownable.

I thought about what we admire in writing. A dozen or more factors may strike us as fine craftsmanship, and we may at various times accept differing conclusions. We may mix-and-match, perhaps appearing contradictory to others but no doubt consistent without our own mind.

Take for instance our own B.K. Stevens’ collection, Her Infinite Variety. I read the first two stories featuring Iphigenia Woodhouse and her professor mother. You will not find characters like them elsewhere. They’re engaging and Mrs Prof Woodhouse, well… She’s the kind of person you’d affectionately delight in unless she was your own mother. Then you’d frantically Google ‘matricide’. In discussing the characters, Bonnie mentions Nero Wolfe, but it’s more complicated than that: Little Harriet plays an Archie Goodwin to Iphigenia, and the formidable Iphigenia plays an Archie to her mother, the professor. If it sounds complicated, it’s simply fun.

Following are a few writing criteria that could appeal to us readers.
Technically Correct
In some ways, this is both the most and least obvious, the English teacher criterion. We don’t notice the mechanics until bad grammar, spelling, or punctuation intrudes upon our consciousness. An author has to do is get the basics right, but a writer like Art Taylor is much more than an English professor.
Character
Jan Grape is able to sketch characters without bogging the reader in descriptions. Most of us enjoy character-driven stories and we tend to remember great characters from Atticus Finch to Hannibal Lector. Mysteries found in Elizabeth Peters’s Amelia Peabody / Ramses series aren’t especially noteworthy, but her characters in the larger storied context are wonderful. As Steve Liskow points out, your character is your brand.
Plot
I admire a clever plot. Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl and Scott Turow’s Presumed Innocent strike me as clever, clever plots. The versatile John Floyd has dreamed up hundreds of smart plot lines.
Beautiful, Poetic
Moving, Powerful
Descriptive: Visual, Aural (5+ Senses)
Sometimes the writing is so elegant, we follow it instead of the action. Janice Law, for example, uses word art. A personal opinion poll reveals in no particular order: Baudelaire, Willian Shakespeare, Charles Dickens, Emily Bronte, John Updike, Vladimir Nabokov, Marcel Proust, David Foster Wallace, William H. Gass, John Steinbeck, Cormac McCarthy, Flannery O’Connor, Thomas Pynchon, William Faulkner, Ernest Hemingway, Dylan Thomas, James Joyce, Jack Kerouac, Thomas Wolfe, Salman Rushdie, Tao Lin, Shirley Jackson, Barbara Kingsolver, Virginia Woolf.
Clever Wording
Clever Wordplay
While the above are noted for their word-smithing, Chaucer and Voltaire are known for misdirection. Voltaire says one thing but means another. Similarly, Chaucer is equally hard to pin down.
I enjoy wonderful wording on a small scale. Erika Jahneke may be disabled, but her writing dances: “Lotta gimps, lotta problems. Nobody I see all day has a leg to stand on.” “Flirtatiousness is not usually considered an independent-living goal.” “As a human being, his best ratings would come if God graded on the curve.”
I find a few mystery writers particularly rewarding in their descriptions: John Lutz, Sue Grafton, Caroline Graham, Brian Freemantle, F. Paul Wilson, Michael Marshall Smith, Dean Koontz, John Grisham, Nelson DeMille, Noah Hawley, Susan Dunlop, Sparkle Hayter, and Anne Perry. Short story specialist Rob Lopresti is another smart, smart word guy.
Descriptively Precise, Accurate
Exact writing is highly valued in technical writing and legal circles, but beyond brain surgery and rocket science, accuracy is critical when baking a cake, sewing a shirt, or building a boat. When it comes to fiction, Michael Crichton comes to mind. Likewise, James Lincoln Warren uses great precision in his historical novels. I also point to our Melissa Yi’s Hope Sze medical series. And then we come to a special case, Brian Thornton. Who else would dare write The Book of Bastards?
Informative
Some authors are known for authentic minutiae, whether historical or relating to some specialized subject such as archeology, glass-blowing, or bell-ringing… or economics like Eve Fisher, spying by David Edgerley Gates, and old Parisian pickpockets by RT Lawton. Our Paul Marks lovingly describes historical Los Angeles and O'Neil De Noux depicts New Orleans much as Jeffrey Deaver paints New York City. The trick is to make the subjects interesting, not bore the reader with useless trivia, but allow an open reader to gather a little knowledge. I’ve written a short story (yes, I know I should submit it sometime) of an actual mystery set in the British Midlands. It’s accurate down to fine details including names, documents, and court testimony.
Funny
Janet Evanovich is known for her humor in her Stephanie Plum series. Likewise our Melodie Campbell writes comedy, combining droll with drama. Barb Goffman writes gentle pieces from absurd situations such as kidnapping a groundhog.
Clever Cultural References
At one time, educated people were well-versed in classical literature. At a minimum, everyone understood the Holy Bible and many had at least a smattering of Greek and Roman mythology. Mention Sisyphus or Cerebus, Scylla or Charybdis, and listeners knew who you were talking about. To be sure, Harry Potter draws upon classic literature and mythology, but these days audiences are more likely to expect pop references.
Clever White Space
You may wonder about this item. This falls in the less-is-more category. While shorter chapters and less dense wording allow text to ‘breathe’, they won’t by themselves mend bad prose. But in this situation, consider Lindsey Davis’ Falco series. In One Virgin Too Many, she has two or three chapters in a row with about the same number of sentences. Why? She uses the technique to portray an intimate seduction scene. Trust me, it works.
Clever Bland
How can bland represent good writing? Most of the previous examples draw attention to the author, especially the beautiful and the cleverly descriptive. The story slows or even stops as the reader ponders the golden words on the page. But a more subtle writer, perhaps self-effacing but certainly disciplined, secrets himself behind the scenes, letting the puppets entertain the audience without making them aware of his (or her) presence. Ideally the story maintains a brisk pace allowing the reader to submerge in the setting among the characters and the plot. Lee Child impresses me as an author who disdains frills; he stands back and lets the action do the talking. That says a lot.

As Julie Andrews or John Coltrane might say, these are a few of my favorite things. What constitutes fine writing in your book?