20 November 2026

Donald Harvey - Angel of Death or Stone Cold Killer?



 In 1987, authorities investigated the death of a motorcyclist, John Powell. A toxicology report revealed cyanide in his system. Powell died at Drake Hospital (now the Drake Center, which is shutting down soon.) Several employees were interviewed. Suspicion fell upon an orderly, Donald Harvey. Soon, WCPO anchor Pat Minarcin dug into Harvey's history. It turned out he had been dismissed from Cincinnati's VA hospital for suspicious behavior. Before long, it became apparently several people might have died by Harvey's hand. 

Harvey was born in Butler County, Ohio, in 1952, but raised near London, Kentucky, just north of the Tennessee border. He was abused as a child, which may or may not have played into his later crimes. However, it did not excuse them. After 37 admitted murders, courts tend to discount the insanity defense.

Harvey went to work for Marymount Hospital in 1970 at the age of 18. His first victim was 88 year old Logan Evans. Evans was a difficult patient whom Harvey smothered. When caught finally in 1987, Harvey claimed he was a mercy killer. Evans's death debunks that notion. Evans clearly had dementia. He was violent at times and even smeared feces on Harvey's face. Harvey retaliated by using a pillow and a plastic bag to smother him. By the time Harvey left Marymount in 1971, nine people died of what appeared to be natural causes only for Harvey to confess them sixteen years later to avoid the death penalty.

So how did he get away with it?  Turning off patients' oxygen. Changing the medication in their IVs. In several cases, he smothered them. 

 Four years after leaving Marymount, Harvey had moved to Cincinnati, where he began working for the VA in 1975. The bulk of his murder spree happened here, and with the same tactics. Eventually, he got caught.

Not committing murder. He was fired for stealing body parts. Harvey had taken to performing occult rituals. Was that connected to his penchant for killing patients? The Satanic Panic of the 1980s would say yes, but Harvey started killing people long before his interest in the occult.

So naturally, Drake Hospital, now the Drake Center for Rehabilitation, hired him as an orderly. It proved to be Harvey's downfall. His final victim, a motorcyclist named John Powell, came to Drake in a coma after an accident. Powell died at Drake, and a pathologist grew suspicious and did a deeper dive on Powell's toxicology. He found cyanide. Police questioned employees and zeroed in on Harvey. 

Enter Pat Minarcin, in the late 1980s, an anchor for Channel 9 WCPO. An employee at Drake voiced suspicions about Harvey to him. Minarcin did some digging. Soon, the extent of Harvey's crimes became apparent. After Minarcin's reporting, prosecutors confronted Harvey. How many people did he kill? Confess all of them, or they would go for the death penalty. Harvey admitted to thirty-seven murders but insisted he did it to end his victims' suffering. After some of the deaths were re-examined, the prosecutors stopped believing him. He was convicted of all 37 counts. 

In prison, however, came to light he had possibly killed 87 people. By that point, he was in the Toledo Correctional Facility. In 2017, like Jeffrey Dahmer before him, he was murdered himself by a fellow inmate. 

19 November 2026

Books Will Teach You the Strangest Things...


It's amazing what you can learn from books, and I mean inadvertently, unexpectedly, and having nothing to do with either the subject (nonfiction) or the plot (fiction).  There you are, tooling along, enjoying a good read, and all of a sudden there's a nugget of information or a flashlight showing you something you never knew before, but it makes perfect sense.  

CAIN & BISCUITS

For example, Mildred Pierce.  Besides being (imho) in the top canon of James M. Cain novels, and having one of the greatest soliloquies on coloratura soprano bitches that has ever been written, and capturing a certain place and time in California - it's where I learned to make biscuits.  You see, when Mildred opens her first restaurant, Cain gives us an exact description of how she sets up the kitchen, with all the food and its preparation, and buried in that is the simple line, "She made piecrust for biscuits."  

Piecrust:  take flour and salt, mix it up, cut in Crisco or lard until it's crumbly, then add cold water and mix with your floury hands until it's back together and fold it over a few times, and stick it in the fridge until it's very, very cold.  Then roll it out.

Biscuits:  take flour, salt, baking powder & mix; cut in crisco / lard / butter (depends on how badly your heart is clogged) cut it in till crumbly, add buttermilk and mix gently with your floury hands until it's back together, fold it over a few times, roll it out and cut your biscuits.  Bake at 425 degrees 10-15 minutes.

WARNING!  NO BISCUITS INVOLVED!

More recently, thanks to the current state of the world, while I'm still reading mysteries and noir and some sci-fi, I have added smutty British rom-coms to my reading list, because the British have great slang, no filters, and the kind of sardonic, sarcastic, often weird humor I like.   

So, I was reading my way through Susie Tate's Daydreamer series (Daydreamer, Gold-digger, and Outlier), which is a fun read, and in which each novel has characters who are neurodivergent to one degree or another.  (Series is available HERE)  

Neurodivergent describes a person whose brain functions, learns, and processes information in ways that differ from the societal or statistical "norm" (known as being neurotypical). While neurodivergent individuals often navigate distinct daily challenges—such as executive dysfunction, sensory overload, or communication differences—many also possess unique cognitive strengths. These can include heightened creativity, hyper-focus, strong pattern recognition, visual-spatial abilities, or unique problem-solving perspectives: 


 And by the time I finished Outlier, I realized there's a strong probability that I am, and always have been, neurodivergent myself.  So I did what any good neurodivergent would do:  I researched it.  Exhaustively.  And started ticking off the boxes.

Common signs and symptoms:

Social and Communication Differences

  • Exhausting social settings: Finding group gatherings, small talk, or crowded environments draining or confusing.  
    • YEP, but I’m better at this than I used to be.  I still HATE going to a party / gathering / conference where I don't know anyone at all.  But I have learned how to go up and actually introduce myself to people and "get acquainted."  
  • Direct communication: Preferring blunt, literal, or information-heavy communication rather than social conventions or subtext. 
    • YEP.  Unless I'm with friends... then anything goes.
  • Interpreting social cues: Missing subtle facial expressions, body language, or unwritten rules of conversation. 
    • NOT ME.  You grow up in an alcoholic household and later spend a couple of years on the streets, and you develop a constant hyperawareness of your surroundings and people, because...  Or at least, I have.

Sensory Processing Patterns

  • Sensory sensitivities or overload: Being easily overwhelmed by bright lights, loud noises, specific clothing textures, or strong smells. 
    • YEP.  Strong perfume or chemicals both give me headaches, itchy clothing is out, and I hate casinos because the lights and the noise make my heart pound, my head ache, and give me a great urge to go home and sit in the dark, drinking.  
  • Stimming: Using repetitive movements or sounds—such as hand-flapping, rocking, foot-tapping, or covert fidgeting—to self-regulate or release internal energy.  
    • YEP.  When I was a little girl, I had certain rituals I did as I moved through the house to make sure I wasn't captured by something...  And I still do a lot of (I hope) subtle covert fidgeting / hand rubbing when I'm in a meeting with a strange group of people.  
    • Oh, and did I mention selective mutism, which is a common reaction of juveniles to trauma?  When 3 year old me came to this country, my mother wouldn't let anyone speak Greek to me, because she wanted me to learn English ASAP and become American ASAP.  The result is that I didn't say a word to anyone for at least three months...  But, when I did speak at last, it was English, so she was happy.  
  • Hyposensitivity: Under-responding to certain sensory inputs, leading to a constant need for movement, deep pressure, or high-intensity sensation. 
    • NOT ME  
    • Except when having to undergo unpleasant or painful things, and then I press extremely hard on my thumb and do steady breathing as a distraction.
  • Masking: Spending massive amounts of energy consciously or unconsciously mimicking neurotypical behavior to "fit in".  
    • Story of my life.

Executive Functioning and Focus

  • Focus extremes: Experiencing intense hyperfocus on special interests or passion projects, alongside severe difficulty initiating or completing mundane tasks.  
    • YEP
    • I go down rabbit holes of research at the drop of a hat, which is why I have five tons of trivia in my brain that I will cheerfully pull out and tell whoever I'm with at great length until I finally catch on that everyone's had enough, or more than enough, thank you.  
    • And oh, how I love doing research!  It's like crack for my brain, which keeps telling me go on, go on, go on!!!!  Four hours later I come back with a crick in my back and twisted hands, but with that gleam of triumph in my eyes...  And deep satisfaction in my heart...  And another batch of information to dump on someone...
  • Planning and organization struggles: Chronic challenges with time management, procrastination, keeping track of belongings, or following multi-step instructions.  
    • Not so much.  Well, at home I can put off sorting out my filing cabinet forever, but I will meet deadlines, I really do know where everything is (ask my husband), and I can follow a multi-step instruction to set up a medical portal, which actually may be another example of  neurodivergence because it is so satisfying when it's done.
  • Demand avoidance: A strong internal resistance or stress response to external demands or loss of autonomy.  
    • YEP, YEP, YEP, YEP and YEP.
    • Everything from that selective mutism to running away from home to... well, let's not go down the whole damn list.  Try to put me in a cage and see what happens. It's not pretty. It will not end well.  

Emotional Intensity and Regulation

  • Strong emotions: Experiencing feelings deeply, sometimes coupled with alexithymia (difficulty identifying or putting words to one's emotions).  
    • YEP
  • Rejection Sensitive Dysphoria (RSD): A sharp, painful emotional reaction to perceived criticism, rejection, or failure.   
    • YEP  
    • Like an elephant, you never forget.  But it can lead to some really good writing.
  • Burnout and anxiety: Chronic mental fatigue, burnout, or co-occurring anxiety and depression resulting from navigating a world designed primarily for neurotypical brains.  
    • YEP.  
    • You see, my brain never shuts down.  I have to keep it occupied with research or deep reading or writing, because otherwise it wanders around like it's in a tunnel that's bouncing with words and images and ideas and... it never stops.  One thing always leads to another, and that's the way it is.
    • And, other than Ambien, There are only a few things that shut it off completely like being outside (walking, sitting, breathing, hiking), long showers or baths (I find saunas claustrophobic), anything where my body takes over (yes, that definitely includes sex) and gives the brain a rest.  

POSSIBLE STRENGTHS:

  • Better memory (yes, it's a freaking 5 dimensional filing cabinet in there).
  • The ability to solve complex mathematical calculations in one's head (I'm really good at math, and my auditor father taught me a lot of tricks to calculate paper free), and many more. 
  • Being able to mentally picture three-dimensional (3D) objects easily.  When I was a child, I'd look at pictures like this and get vertigo, because it turned 3-D in my mind so quickly. 


WHO KNOWS WHO WE REALLY ARE?

We grow up constantly being told who / what / how we are, should be, always have been, always will be, etc.  And then one day, many of us turn around and go, "That's not me."  Some people stay put, because it's way too scary to set food outside the parameters.  Some people hide, and let themselves out only on full moons in wintertime.  Some people get fed up and tap out - off to the bar, the wilderness, wherever.  Anywhere but here is the mantra.  Some search, ceaselessly, for an explanation.  And a great place to start is in books.  

So read, read, read, from trash to classics, from mysteries to cookbooks, anything and everything, because sooner or later, you'll read something that will open a door for you that nothing else has...  


After that, you're on your own.  




18 November 2026

Author Events, in Person



 You may remember that last month Joseph Walker asked members of the Short Mystery Fiction Society for advice on participating in a multi-author event.  With Joe's permission and that of the contributors I compiled a useful collection of suggestions.

Last Sunday I had the chance to put them to the test. The Whatcom County Library System sponsored an event called Open Book at the Ferndale Event Center.  I shared a table with Karen Rabe who writes thrillers and children books under the name Karen Charles.  


How did it go? Great! Approximately 800 people attended and I sold ten books.  Here are some observations, some of which may pass as advice.

* They let us come in at 10:30. The event ran from noon to five.  I didn't need 90 minutes to set up but I appreciated the chance to walk around and visit with the other exhibitors before the doors opened.  

* The WCLS provided tablecloths and nice signs with our names, but I don't regret bringing a tablecloth and a  sign. The latter is especially important in case they misspell your name. Hey, it can happen.


* The crowds stayed pretty steady until 4 but for some reason, most of my sales were in the  first two hours.  

* I had conversations (beyond "hello") with 83 people. I wish I had been a tad more aggressive with trying to engage with the "hello" crowd. As you will see below, finding a way to start a conversation is the key.

* "Do you like to read?"
"No."
"Do you have friends who like to read?"
"No."
"Then why the hell are you here?" (This last line was strictly in my head.)
 
 * Candy bowls! Have one if it's permitted but remember that candy is bait and decide who you are trying to catch.  In other words, the author of children's books would be advised to provide something different than the adult author would.  I found that Andes mints worked well for my audience.  

* Something cool I blundered onto: If you have a bowl of candy make sure to have a wastebasket with a plastic bag in it. Not only is that neat and hygienic, but maybe a third of adults who grab a piece of candy will stick around to unwrap it and toss the wrapper in your can.  That gives you five precious seconds to start a conversation.
 
* I had cards advertising two of my books sitting on the table but I should have been handing them out to the chatters, not waiting for them to notice them.

* Besides my novels and collections I had copies of my hardcover nonfiction book. This was produced by an academic publisher, aimed at libraries, and was originally priced way too high for the average buyer.  One woman (in her twenties) was interested so I warned her about the (deeply discounted) price.  She calmly produced a $100 bill and added two other books to her pile.  Surprised me. (And no, it wasn't counterfeit.)
  
 

* A good way to start a conversation: Compliment their clothes, purse, etc., especially if they are relevant.  One man had a T-shirt promoting A Clockwork Orange by Anthony Burgess, and was wearing a cap from The Strand Bookstore.  Plenty to talk about!
 
* I had six books for sale, all wildly different from each other.  I had to be able to point at each one and give a snappy one sentence explanation.  By the end my brain could not compute it.  A phrase like "folk music revival" sounded like gibberish to me.

* One of the SMFS members suggested wearing a shirt with your book cover. That reminded me that my sister Joann Scanlon had a shirt made for me with the cover of an Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine featuring one of my stories. It got some attention and I gave away two copies of old AHMMs.  One young woman: "My grandmother used to read that! Thank you!" I would have given out a third but a paying customer, bless him, intervened.
  
Stuff I brought to the Event

* "Do you like  to read?"
"No. But, hey, let me tell you about a new book you really should read..."

 * Bring all the supplies you'd want to find in an office desk: scissors, Scotch tape, rubber bands, etc.  I found use for all of them.

* I had a QR code printed out for my page but never thought to have a QR code for my Paypal account, and that would have been useful.

* I brought a clipboard and a note saying sign up for a chance to win a book, but the table was so crowded I never put it out. Didn't seem like it was a good use of time to tell them about it either.



* One suggestion was to wear a name tag. I brought one but didn't wear it. It didn't seem necessary since I was standing behind a table that had a big sign with my name on it and I was wearing a t-shirt with my name on a magazine cover. But a couple of people asked if I was the author, so maybe I should have put it on?

* I have CDs of my songs and many people don't even have CD players anymore so I offered a free one to anyone who bought a book. Most buyers took one. I realized late in the game that I should have explained that it contained songs I had written and performed. Some people thought they contained my stories...


*If you have to eat at your table take small bites.  You never know when a potential victim, I mean customer, might stop by and force you to swallow fast. 

It was great fun. But standing in one place for five hours is bloody exhausting.

Would I do it again? Probably not until I had a new book to sell, but then, definitely.

And thanks to the wonderful people at the Whatcom County Library System and to everyone for the advice! 

 

17 November 2026

The Quiet Impact of Stories and Books


I certainly can't speak for all authors, but I still feel this is a universal truth: writers write to be read. We spend our time coming up with fun stories, shocking twists, cool murder methods, and characters we wish were real. We spend days, weeks, months (maybe even years) writing our stories and novels until we're happy enough with them to share them with the world. And then we wait for reviews.

In some circumstances, we wait and wait and wait.

With so many books published compared to the number of readers out there (and the even smaller number of readers who review combined with the small number of professional reviewers), it really shouldn't be a surprise that most books get little feedback. It's nothing personal. But still, it can hurt to have poured your heart out onto the page and hear crickets.

It's times like this, when I'm contemplating the crickets, that I remind myself of something I've said over the years: You have to enjoy the journey. You have to enjoy writing, because there is no guarantee your book will be published, that your story will be read, that a reader will put pen to paper (or fingers to keyboard) to tell you how much they loved it. 

You have to trust that what you wrote matters to someone, even if you never hear about it.

I was reminded of this today while reading on social media about an acquaintance whose husband sadly died just a few days ago. As her family went through his bookshelves, they found a signed book, and they were reminded of the wonderful day they all went to hear the author read and how they got his signature. The memory brought them comfort. 

When my father died more than a decade ago, I too was comforted by a book. The death had been unexpected, and I found myself unable to concentrate on anything--until I settled down with one of Louise Penny's books. Her story drew me in, allowing me to briefly set aside my pain. For that I will be forever grateful. 

So I offer this reminder to my fellow authors: Believe in yourself and your writing. You may not get a lot of reviews, but it doesn't mean your work isn't being read. It doesn't mean you aren't having an impact. Something you wrote could be the very thing that is helping someone emerge from grief or depression. It could be the thing that will help someone get through a bad day tomorrow. It could be the thing that is making someone smile right now.

Indeed, I once received an email from a hospitalized woman. While she was recuperating, she read my collection. She then took the time to tell me that my work had made her feel better. I can only hope I made her feel as good as her email made me feel.

I don't get a lot of emails like that, but I like to believe there are more readers out there who enjoy my work, even if I don't hear about it. I hope, my fellow authors, that the same is true for you. 

16 November 2026

Tyger, tyger


           When I published my first novel, I knew nothing about crime writing, book marketing, publishing or the mystery community, even if there was such a thing.  My first move was to go to the late and lamented Black Orchid Bookshop in New York and talk to Bonnie Claeson, who squandered over an hour counseling me while hopeful customers lined up to actually buy some of Bonnie and Joe’s books.

            Her first piece of advice was to go to Bouchercon and hang out in the bar.  This, I thought, was something I knew how to do.  Thus I stumbled like a castaway on a remote shore into a vast, welcoming realm of erudition and bottomless generosity.  In addition to getting some words into print, this was the best thing about the whole experience.


            I went to Crime Bake last week, New England’s regional conference held up near Boston.  I love this conference for all the reasons shared by the commentators and panelists.  It’s small, intimate, embracing and committed to serving the interests of writers at every level of the pursuit. 

            

            As we all agreed, you learn something valuable every time you go, and the pearl of wisdom I brought home is that no one involved in this world knows anything.  To put this in context, the screenwriter William Goldman notoriously said the same thing about Hollywood.  “Nobody knows anything.”  What’s missing from this is the rest of his quote: “Not one person in the entire motion picture field knows for a certainty what's going to work. Every time out it's a guess and, if you're lucky, an educated one.”

            

            In the past, it might have been possible for someone in the movie or publishing business to have captured at least a modest percentage of what is knowable.  There were certain rhythms and norms, a conventional process with intimations of predictability.  But after two decades of economic upheaval, lunatic politics, plagues and digital dismemberment of established institutions, all bets are apparently off.


           So I’ve come full circle.  I now know a container ship volume of information about this endeavor that I didn’t know before, and it’s worth just about as much as the air in the pockets of my jeans before I throw them in the wash.

            That is, if practicality was the only measure.  I once picked up another bit of wisdom from an advertising creative director, as unlikely a source as you can conceive.  He said, “The only things that matter in life are the people you love and the experiences you have.” By that calculation, my life is way ahead on the deal, and my association with the crime writing community, and all the contrary characters who inhabit it, is a major contributor.


            A stockbroker friend of mine tells me that the one circumstance Wall Street loathes more than any other is uncertainty.  It’s fitting that the people at the center of the planet’s greatest concentration of wealth revere certainty, a commodity that is virtually non-existent.  A supply and demand ratio that calculates to about zero to 100%.     

           

            It’s William Blake’s fearful symmetry.  Innocence is the state of certainty, uncertainty the price of experience.  If you’re lucky, you can get comfortable with what is basically the human condition.  The writing life, as it’s presently configured, may then be the best of all possible worlds. 

15 November 2026

Sherlock Holmes and an English Fry-Up


Stephen Fry as Mycroft Holmes
Stephen Fry as Mycroft Holmes

I’m keeping today’s introduction short because you’ll want to read the linked article without a lot of fanfare and blather. The article is about Sherlock Holmes and Stephen Fry, brought to us with thanks by our long-time reader, ABA, occasionally known as Cate. She was particularly amused by the article’s reference to HOLMES, acronym of Britain’s criminal database titled Home Office Large Major Enquiry System.

I’m assuming you know Stephen Fry, the English actor, humourist, television presenter, and good friend of Hugh Laurie who played the titular doctor in House. Fry read the British version of the Harry Potter series. (Jim Dale read the North American version.)

Fry hosted the first 13 years of QI, the ‘Quite Interesting’ BBC quiz show that isn’t a quiz show, before handing it over to Sandi Toksvig. QI also features actor/comedian Alan Davies, whom you might recognize from British mystery series including Jonathan Creek, The Brief, and Agatha Cristie’s Marple.

Returning to Stephen Fry, he wrote a pastiche about Sherlock Holmes along with, as Fry mentions, a catalogue of other writers. Fry also portrayed Mycroft Holmes in A Game of Shadows.

Now that everyone is caught up on who’s who, check out Fry’s description how, as a student, he became the youngest member of the Sherlock Holmes Society of London which nearly ruined his life. Or something like it. Read on, click on:

‘Sherlock Holmes altered the course of my whole life’ by Stephen Fry

P.S. Fry’s article appears in The Guardian. Their reporting contains no paywalls, no pop-up adverts, no overlays, no demands for email addresses, no begging interruptions. At the end of most articles, they simply ask for a donation, even a small one. I like that business model.

14 November 2026

The House That Tasteless Tonic Built


St. Louis, 1890s (Missouri Historical Society)
The doctors gave it to Edwin Grove straight. The St. Louis smog was eating away at him. The haze aggravated his bronchitis and left him wracked with chronic hiccups. He was ailing, sleep-deprived, and filthy rich. The doctors said it was high time he sought clean mountain air. 

This was 1897, and Grove had to admit the doctors were right. He needed a summer retreat. And it wasn't as if he had St. Louis in his bones. He'd grown up in West Tennessee and built his pharmaceutical business there. As his sales boomed, he began moving the operation to St. Louis in 1889 to scale production and build nationwide distribution. By the 1890s, Grove and his Paris Medicine Company had become an industrial powerhouse. 

The industry? Patent health elixirs.

In Grove's case, the anti-malarial Grove's Tasteless Chill Tonic. Grove's tonic had moved ahead in a crowded field of patent-fever medicines, products like Ayer's Ague Cure and Hostetter's Bitters. By 1890, his tasteless tonic reportedly outsold a popular new concoction of coca leaves and kola nuts known as, well, Coca-Cola. Grove was winning because of his marketing machine, but his tonic backed up the hype. Unlike the snake oils of the day, his tonic was genuinely anti-malarial.

Except there was a catch.

Malaria was still a major problem in the U.S., especially across the South, and would remain so for decades. Grove experienced malaria's impact on a personal level, losing a daughter and his first wife to the disease. At the time, the standard treatment for malarial symptoms was quinine powder, an aggressively bitter compound. Quinine could kill the malaria parasite and reduce fever—if you could convince someone to endure the dose. 

Grove's idea was to make quinine palatable. Instead of the traditional powder, he suspended his quinine in syrup with lemon. Was it tasteless? Mostly. Did it have the claimed broad health benefits beyond chills and fever? It did not. But his tonic was soon everywhere, in pharmacies, on corner stores shelves, as mail-order. 

In 1897, it was Grove who needed a cure. Sweet mountain air, and he knew just the place: Asheville, North Carolina.

By the late nineteenth century, Asheville had a burnished reputation as a natural health retreat, with luxury sanitoriums and comforts for the wealthy visitor. Tucked in the French Broad River valley, Asheville offered wide spaces, altitude, a dry climate, and the promise of clean, forested air. America's rich had been coming for treatment but staying for the atmosphere. 

And off Grove went. He bought property in Asheville and summered there while Paris Medicine Company churned out the tonic. And he'd chosen well. The North Carolina climate soon helped relieve his respiratory problems. With a clear head and a good night's sleep, his attention turned from convalescence to opportunity. 

This time, the product was Asheville itself. The town lived up to its billing: healthful and skilled at catering to the wealthy. As the summer estates went up, an entire community of designers and artisans set up shop downtown. Asheville was so attractive that even the artists decided to stay. 

And the land was cheap. 

Grove bought entire swathes of Asheville real estate. By 1908, he was selling his first lots at a sprawling development on the lower slope of Sunset Mountain north of downtown. Grove Park, it would be called, and it wouldn't be just a neighborhood. Grove Park would be a lifestyle. Grand houses, wooded roads, hillside views, and common spaces to enjoy the restorative air. Money didn't buy happiness, but it could buy a lot in Grove Park, and a Grove Park lot promised a healthier constituion. 

Empty hills and hype wouldn't convince Grove's educated buyers into signing contracts. Closing a sale meant proving that his development was more than a pitch--and, of course, that he had the financial muscle to deliver.

Grove needed big and thought big: a mountain inn centerpiece overlooking the development. Part lodge and part spa, an impressive inn could serve as a draw and convenient housing for potential buyers. Its design would advertise Grove Park's planned aesthetic from on high. 

There was a problem: Grove's vision for the inn was so singular that no architect captured it to his satisfaction. The big firms brought him urban refinement, symmetry, a city hotel or a sanitarium perched atop Sunset Mountain. No, Grove said, the inn must be carved into the mountainside, a part of it.

Finally, Grove let his son-in-law have a shot at the design. To be clear, the son-in-law, chemist Fred Loring Seely, had no architectural experience. He'd been busy running much of the Tasteless Tonic business. But he understood Grove and the objective, and he wanted a chance to pitch a design. 

The folklore goes that Seely brought Grove a design for a raw stone lodge built around a grand hall. In reality, Seely seems to have drawn on earlier proposals. Either way, he had a winning concept. From the front, the inn would look broad, low, and deliberately simple, a lodge as old as the Blue Ridge chain itself. At the rear, the inn extended six stories down the mountain, with rooms positioned to maximize the mountain views. Grove tasked his son-in-law to make it happen. 

The inn broke ground in 1912. Seely had no background in construction, either, but he had logistical know-how and Grove's deep pockets. Seely quickly hired professional engineers and four hundred men at high wages and set everyone to work. Both Seely and his crew lived on Sunset Mountain while the Inn took shape. They pried granite from the immediate area and used it in its natural shape, cracks and lichens and all. Stones that men or donkeys couldn't move were incorporated into the design. 

About a year later, the Grove Park Inn was finished. Grove, however, was not. Until his death in 1927, he continued to develop Grove Park into one of Asheville's premier addresses, which it remains to today. The inn grew into a hospitality complex, and his patent medicine business grew to add brands such as Laxative Bromo-Quinine (for colds), Dr. Porter's Antiseptic Healing Oil, and Pazo Ointment (for hemorrhoids). Bristol Myers bought the company in 1957. 

Before all that, though, was a terrible case of hiccups and the doctors' order for a tonic baron to get some damn fresh air. Go to the mountains, the doctors told Grove. He took his ambition with him.