13 January 2018

On Crime Reporting

Libby Cudmore
I was up early Jan. 1, 2017. I wanted to start the New Year off right, that is, writing. Also, I had trouble sleeping. I blamed the champagne.

As such, I was the first person in Upstate New York to see the press release from Doug Brenner, the Oneonta Police Lieutenant who was set to be named Interim Chief that Thursday, stating that Joshua Underwood had been arrested for bludgeoning his boyfriend, Mark Morrison, to death with a 25 pound weight after a fight just after the dawn of the New Year.

It was 8 a.m. “Doug,” I groaned when I called him for details. “You have got to be kidding me.”

“Tell me about it,” he said in a voice I would soon get very familiar with.

I got a sinking feeling that this was a harbinger of things to come. And I was right. Jesus Christ, I was right. In 2017, I covered five homicides – including one with two victims – and two attempted murders. To put that in perspective, from Dec. 2009, when I started working for the Freeman’s Journal/Hometown Oneonta, until Dec. 31, 2016, I’d covered a total of three murders, and my boss covered one. Three of them were murder/suicides, so there’s no trial to follow up on. The other, Michael Buck, was charged with the shooting death of his father in 2013 and plead guilty.

The Underwood case was big news.  And we thought it had died down, until June, when I found myself talking to a Sheriff’s Deputy outside a ramshackle scattering of sheds and campers that served as a domicile for Perry Webb, Arthur Bellinger and Scott Littlefield—until Webb stomped Bellinger’s head to a pulp and nearly caused the same fatality to Littlefield. Webb was found incompetent to stand trial in Nov. and remains hospitalized.

Then came August, when the battered body of 11 year old JacelynO’Connor was retrieved from a trailer in Norwich, where her half-brother’s father, James Brower, and his boyfriend, Tobias Rundstrom-Wooding allegedly raped and smothered her. Once you’ve covered the rape and murder of an 11 year old girl, well, all other crimes pale a little in comparison. By Christmas, when 23 year old Kevin Perry was accused of shooting his parents in their trailer in Laurens, I was almost bored with murder.

(Almost. I’m only human, after all, and nothing can beat the thrill of covering a big case.)

But reporting on crime made me a better crime writer because it made me respect what murder does to families. What it does to a community. That these crimes don’t exist in a vacuum, they aren’t forgotten with a tilt of a fedora or a witty remark. Gone was any hardboiled pastiche and in its place was a better understanding of how police solve a case, the methodical detailing that goes into small-town crime fighting. I talked on and off the record with detectives, investigators and our bulldog of DA, who tried and convicted CaseyCallahan, finally charged last year with the 2001 murder of his wife, Lizzy Welsh.

The best crime writing isn’t about the blood splatters at the scene or a gun with a muzzle still warm from a bullet. The best crime writing is about the people involved, how it affects them, how it ripples outward. Because it changes you. I’m just a bystander and I know that I’m changed. I think about Jacelyn almost every day. I’m never going to not know what I read in those files, the details I couldn’t print because they were just too brutal.

But even the darkest, most brutal writings need to have a human heart involved or they’re just a fedora on a page, a bunch of gaudy patter that means nothing.

New Year’s Day 2018 dawned quiet. I was still up too early, but my inbox was empty of press releases, and remained empty.  The next day, I texted Doug Brenner, who was officially appointed as Police Chief last May. We made it through the first day, I wrote.

We did, he wrote back. Happy New Year.


  1. Great column (again!), Libby. Heartbreaking, insightful. Much appreciated.

  2. Excellent column. Murder has a tremendous impact on families, communities, and especially small towns, where they will be whispered about, analyzed, dissected, and linger for years. Thanks for the reminder.

  3. You are absolutely right about the human side of crime and its wider impact. I suspect much crime writing and mystery novels spend time trying to evade that in an effort to keep the appalling entertaining.

  4. An excellent column, Libby, and a great reminder that if we tell our stories well, our characters will never be the same again. Life changes you, but the death of someone close to you changes you even more.

    And the truth is disturbing...

  5. A great column. No question, crime changes not only the victim & the perp but everybody around them. I've known at least three people who killed someone, and almost 20 years ago the son of a dear friend was murdered in a road rage incident.

  6. Emotional and thoughtful article, Libby. Nice job, lady.

  7. Excellent story for the New Year!


Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>