Okay, I know that's an odd title. Here's a bit of backstory, before I get to the main topic.
Ideas for SleuthSayers columns can come in unexpected ways. A few days ago I finished a sort of noir short story about a dumb guy and his smart girlfriend on the run from the mob, and--since I write stories like a chainsmoker, lighting up a new one as soon as the old one's done--I was about to start writing another tale, this one about two rednecks searching for hidden treasure on one of the islands off the Mississippi Coast. But I also found myself thinking about the writing itself, thinking about how much fun it always is for me to type THE END on one story and then forget about it and write a totally different story after that--maybe even one in a different genre. That's what keeps all this from getting boring. And while these thoughts were zinging around in my mind, my wife called to me and told me to check the Facebook page of one of our daughters-in-law because some new pictures had just been posted of three of our seven grandchildren. So I did.
Hang on, I'm getting there.
As ordered, I hopped over to Facebook and took a look at the photos of our (fantastic, if I do say so myself) grandkids, and as I was about to go back to my Word program and my new story, I happened to see another Facebook post. This one said something like "Did you know the actor who played Wilson in Cast Away was the same one in the volleyball scene in Top Gun?"
I gotta tell you, I liked that. I'm easily entertained anyway, and I thought that was cute. And since I had a SleuthSayers post coming up that I hadn't even started on, it got me thinking about something else. I'm a card-carrying movie addict, and I've always suspected that movie and TV actors, like writers, enjoy trying different kinds of projects--different characters, different genres, etc. Unless they're actors committed to a series, I doubt they want to play the same roles, or even the same kinds of roles, over and over again. (Even Wilson.)
Anyhow, all that is what led to this column, and to this question:
Who are some actors who have played extremely different roles in different movies, roles so against type that you almost didn't know who they were?
Remember Charlize Theron in Monster? Or Sean Connery in The Untouchables? It was hard to believe he was James Bond. And did Indiana Jones once pilot the Millennium Falcon? Surely not--but those two guys sure look alike. And how many of us who saw Kathy Bates in Fried Green Tomatoes were goggle-eyed at her performance in Misery? The more I thought about this, the more movies and roles I came up with. Was I honestly supposed to believe Richard Harris in Camelot and Richard Harris in Unforgiven were the same man? How could that nice Air Force captain who Dreamed of Jeannie become a devil like J.R. Ewing? Had Robin Wright in House of Cards really been Forrest Gump's girlfriend, and the Princess Bride?? How had Rocky morphed into Rambo? I could easily imagine Joe Moviegoer sitting in a theater in Bugtussle, Oklahoma, watching the villain in Once Upon a Time in the West murder an entire family, suddenly elbowing his wife and saying, "Look, I think that's Henry Fonda!"
So here, without further ado, is a list of fifty actors who--in my opinion--played shockingly different characters, sometimes polar opposites, in different productions, and the movies/TV shows featuring those characters:
Lee Marvin -- The Dirty Dozen and Cat Ballou
Donald Sutherland -- M*A*S*H and The Hunger Games
Jane Fonda -- Nine to Five and Barbarella
Denzel Washington -- Remember the Titans and Training Day
Jeff Bridges -- The Last Picture Show and The Big Lebowski
Sally Field -- The Flying Nun and Norma Rae
Leonardo DiCaprio -- Titanic and The Revenant
Sigourney Weaver -- Alien and Galaxy Quest
Kurt Russell -- Overboard and Escape from New York
Burt Reynolds -- Smokey and the Bandit and Deliverance
George Clooney -- ER and O Brother Where Art Thou?
Meryl Streep -- Mama Mia! and The Devil Wears Prada
Woody Harrelson -- Cheers and Zombieland
Jeff Daniels -- The Newsroom and Dumb & Dumber
Richard Crenna -- The Real McCoys and Wait Until Dark
John Travolta -- Grease and Pulp Fiction
Lou Diamond Phillips -- La Bamba and Longmire
Bryce Dallas Howard -- The Village and Jurassic World
Keanu Reeves -- The Matrix and Bill & Ted's Excellent Adventure
Elizabeth Taylor -- Giant and Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf?
Tom Hanks -- Splash and Saving Private Ryan
Fred MacMurray -- My Three Sons and Double Indemnity
Dennis Weaver -- Gunsmoke and Duel
Jack Palance -- Shane and City Slickers
Sandra Bullock -- The Blind Side and Miss Congeniality
Daniel Day Lewis -- Lincoln and The Last of the Mohicans
Robert Shaw -- From Russia with Love and Jaws
Lloyd Bridges -- Sea Hunt and Airplane!
Faye Dunaway -- Bonnie and Clyde and Oklahoma Crude
Gregory Peck -- To Kill a Mockingbird and The Boys from Brazil
Frances McDormand -- Fargo and Raising Arizona
Jack Nicholson -- Easy Rider and Chinatown
Scarlett Johansson -- Ghost World and Black Widow
Robert Duvall -- Lonesome Dove and Apocalypse Now
Christian Bale -- Batman Begins and Vice
Michael Douglas -- The American President and Romancing the Stone
Kathleen Turner -- Peggy Sue Got Married and Body Heat
Marlon Brando -- A Streetcar Named Desire and The Godfather
Kevin Costner -- Field of Dreams and 3000 Miles to Graceland
Glenn Close -- The Natural and Fatal Attraction
Eddie Murphy -- Beverly Hills Cop and The Nutty Professor
Kelly McGillis -- Top Gun and Witness
Bruce Willis -- Moonlighting and Sin City
Laura Linney -- The Truman Show and Ozark
Russell Crowe -- Gladiator and L.A. Confidential
Elijah Wood -- Lord of the Rings and Pawn Shop Chronicles
William Holden -- The World of Suzie Wong and The Wild Bunch
Emily Blunt -- Mary Poppins Returns and Edge of Tomorrow
Robin Williams -- Mork & Mindy and Dead Poets Society
Dustin Hoffman -- The Graduate and Midnight Cowboy (and Tootsie, for that matter)
These are some that first came to mind; there are many, many more. Please feel free to add to the list in the comments section. (I love this stuff.)
By the way . . . if you haven't seen Galaxy Quest, believe me, you should. It's streaming now on Amazon Prime.
See you again in two weeks.