07 August 2018

All Hail The New Queen

by Barb Goffman

When I first got involved with the mystery world nearly twenty years ago, I noticed something I thought a bit odd. Mystery writers seemed to love the name Kate. Between published books and unpublished manuscripts I read in writing workshops, I saw fictional Kates everywhere. Then I became program chair of Malice Domestic, and it seemed that practically every third book of a registered author had a protagonist named Kate. I remember thinking one day that you couldn't swing a dead cat (or a nice live cozy one, by the fire, on the cover of a mystery) without hitting an amateur sleuth named Kate who was out to save the day. Even today, we have lots of Kates out there: Dana Stabenow's Kate Shugak, Laurie King's Kate Martinelli, Linda Castillo's Kate Burkholder, and Frances Brody's Kate Shackleton, just to name a few mystery sleuths.

But Kate, my dear girl, I believe your reign is over. Because I've seen a new protagonist on the rise. She's smart, she's sassy, and she is solving crimes EVERYWHERE. Her name is Sarah. (And sometimes Sara.)

I went online to find some Sarahs to tell you all about, and I came up with a dozen in no time at all, living all over the place, and this is just the tip of the iceberg:

  • Sarah Winston solves crimes in Ellington, Massachusetts, when she's not throwing garage sales (and sometimes while she is). This Agatha-nominated amateur-sleuth series is written by Sherry Harris.
  • Sarah Booth Delaney solves crimes in Zinnia, Mississippi, when she's not dealing with a bossy ghost. This series about a southern belle turned private eye is written by Carolyn Haines.

  • Sarah Brandt solves crimes in old New York when she's not delivering babies. This Edgar- and Agatha-nominated series about a midwife turned amateur sleuth in early twentieth-century Manhattan is written by Victoria Thompson.

  • Sarah Grayson solves crimes in North Harbor, Maine, when she's not running her refurbished-goods shop. This series about an amateur sleuth who solves crimes with her cat is written by Sofie Ryan.

  • Dr. Sara Linton gets involved in darker crimes (or at least darker on paper) than the previously mentioned protagonists. This series about a pediatrician and coroner is set in Grant County, Georgia, (before the character moves to Atlanta as part of a second series). This Barry- and Macavity-nominated series is written by Karin Slaughter.

  • Sarah Kelling solves crimes with her art-fraud investigator husband, Max, in Boston. This Anthony-nominated series was written by the late Charlotte MacLeod.

  • Sarah Blair solves crimes in Wheaton, Alabama, when she's not working as a law firm receptionist. This series about an amateur sleuth is scheduled to debut this December. It's written by Debra H. Goldstein. 

The following sleuthy Sarahs I don't know much about (at least not yet):

  • Sarah Woods series written by Jennifer L. Jennings
  •  Sarah Miller series written by Carol Dean Jones
  •  Sarah Hart series written by a series of authors
  •  Sara Mason series written by Mary Deal
  •  Sarah Quilliam series written by Claudia Bishop
I know there are tons more Sarahs (and Saras) out there who are searching for clues as we speak. Dear reader, why do you think Sarah has become so popular for the name of a sleuth? What's your favorite name for a sleuth? (And why?) And please weigh in with names of Sarah mysteries I've missed.

Queen Kate is dead (or at least less popular than before). Long live the new queen, Sarah!


  1. Well, like they say, Kay Sarah Sara...

    It's interesting to think about this, Barb, because as we become more diverse, you'd expect more names to appear, but it seems to be the opposite. I know I always struggle to come up with names for my supporting or minor characters, and even keep a spread sheet so I don't duplicate too often.

    It's hard to come up with a name that's distinctive but doesn't call too much attention to itself, and still tries to capture the character's personality. Some day I'll get better at it.

    I have a "Sarah" as a major character in my last book, but she's not the sleuth. I guess that's fortunate, isn't it?

  2. Easy answer - i’d already used Kate in another story ...... guess I’m subconsciously following the trend in my new Sarah Blair mystery series :)

  3. It is truly amazing, and I noticed the similarities myself.In fact, I often have several books 'open' at any one time and although I pride myself on never confusing the stories,I have to stop and orient myself to WHICH Kate or Sarah each story belongs to when I pick one up that has been languishing in a car or elsewhere.
    Since I assume the writers read their fellows' books, and with all of their own imagination, you'd think they would like to diversify a bit.

  4. My middle name is Sarah. When I was 40-something I went to court & changed my first & middle names, which I always hated. Should have done it before.

    I've heard of "Kate" characters. They run rings around other people. Then there's the "Mary Sue," the "Jenna" & I don't know who all else.

  5. I picked Sarah off a list of names popular for women born in 1976 which when I was writing the book made Sarah 38. Sarah was number 15 (I just looked.)

  6. No Kate, Sarah or Sara for me. The protagonist in my mystery, A Matter of Blood, is NYPD Detective Chiara Corelli. A nice, well maybe not so nice all the time, Italian girl from Brooklyn, NY

  7. I recently named a minor character Kelly, then renamed her Sarah, then realized another character formerly named Selene had become Savannah. I don't think Sarah and Savannah can coexist in such close quarters, but I like both names. Sarah could become Sarah Jo, but that's not quite right. Thanks to you, Barb, I won't be renaming her Kate.

  8. What a fun post! Just when I was thinking there was nothing left to write about...grin. Barb pulls it off. Yes, the names, the names. My most prolific protag is Gina, natch, as she's mob. My latest one - also with a mob past - is Lucy (Lucia.) Yes, I noticed the Sara creep. And now that you have made us aware, I will never use Kate or Sara. See the influence you have, Barb?

  9. Thanks, everyone, for commenting.

    Steve, I've seen a number of characters with unusual names. I wish we had more than anecdotal reports like mine to see what's really going on with names.

    Tonette, I've also experienced reading two books at once with the same names and having a hard time remembering who's who sometimes.

    Catherine, Chiara is certainly unusual. How did you choose it?

    Kathy, really like the name Savannah.

    And Mel, it is hard to come up with ideas, isn't it? I'm happy to help you avoid being trendy.


Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>