Fiction, at its best, does more than just tell a story -- it tells a story in a setting. Good fiction immerses the reader – we are propelled into the narrative and into its setting. And the setting crafted by the author reflects the world around the author, or the author’s characters, at the time of the story. The story told in Victor Hugo’s Les Miserables is part and parcel with the French Revolution. A Dickens novel is often almost as much about setting as it is about story. Oliver Twist is dependent on the injustices that were a side effect, and a very real side effect, of the industrial revolution. And as I noted some months back, Dickens’ A Christmas Carol in fact grew out of a non-fiction essay that Dickens wrote addressing the deplorable mid-nineteenth century working conditions in England and the need for child labor reform.
No surprise, then, that setting is also a major component of great mysteries. Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes cannot be separated from Victorian England. I add the proviso of “Doyle’s Sherlock” since, to my mind, the BBC series Sherlock does a sensational job of re-imagining Holmes in modern day London. But even there, it is modern day London, with its Blackberries and computers, that provides the setting backbone to the stories.
|The Doorbell Rang (NOT the newest Clint Eastwood sequel||!)|
To read these books is to experience what it was like to live in the eras depicted. It is no surprise that all of this remains true today. Two recent (and sensational) new mysteries by a pair of gifted writers, Tana French and Gillian Flynn, who are separated by many thousands of miles, tell stories in different settings, but settings that are still eerily analogous and in each case reflective of our time. More on that below, but first, some background on each author.
Tana French in fact received the Edgar for best first novel when In the Woods, was published the following year Although she was born in the United States, Tana French spent most of her early years abroad. She received a degree in acting from the University of Dublin, and since 1990 has resided in Dublin, where each of her four mystery novels is set.
So, other than leaping into the world of mystery fiction within one year of each other there is very little that either of these women share. Yet each has crafted their most recent novel in settings that, while thousands of miles apart, nevertheless resonate with common themes.
A teaser on Gillian Flynn’s website describes her new book, Gone Girl, as follows:
On a warm summer morning in North Carthage, Missouri, it is Nick and Amy’s fifth wedding anniversary. Presents are being wrapped and reservations are being made when Nick Dunne’s clever and beautiful wife disappears from their rented McMansion on the Mississippi River.And here is the description of Tana French’s new book, Broken Harbor, as set forth on her website:
On one of the half-built, half-abandoned “luxury” developments that litter Ireland, Patrick Spain and his two young children are dead. His wife, Jenny, is in intensive care.
Broken Harbor is set in a community of new homes on the coast of Ireland that failed as a result of the economic downturn that has shaped many lives in recent years. The home that the unfortunate family lives in is surrounded by abandoned or half finished homes, and the couple at the heart of the novel has had to grapple with the horrors of losing a job in an economy where jobs are increasingly hard to find. From that setting, which is to say from their world, the story springs.
And that community of “McMansions” that is the setting for Gone Girl? Well, there are remarkable similarities between Gillian Flynn’s Missouri housing development and that depicted in Tana French’s novel. The couple at the heart of Gillian Flynn’s novel also find themselves in a development that is a casualty of world-wide economic downturn. Like the family in Broken Harbor, the couple in Gone Girl is surrounded by homes that are abandoned and in foreclosure, and other homes that stand as half completed derelicts. As in Broken Harbor neighboring homes are abandoned as a result of foreclosure, or sit half completed. And in each book there are wandering homeless people living or gathering in the empty homes. And here, too, the central characters in the mystery have lost their own jobs as a result of economic downturn.
I have written before that I hate spoilers. So you will get no more of the plots of these wonderful newly-published novels from me. But they are both great reads, and like many mysteries and other well written books over the years, they gain strength from the fact that they are set in a world that we know. The heart of each story beats to the world’s pulse. The setting may be a bit bleak in each case, but, after all, that never stopped Dickens.