25 August 2025

We're only here to help.


            The car I drive every day seems much more concerned about my personal welfare than with getting me from point A to point B.  It won’t let me start up until my foot is on the brake.  If I don’t put on my seatbelt it emits a robotic and relentless clang that supersedes the radio and increases in volume until I’m forced to succumb.  I think the approach is based on similar techniques banned by the Army Field Manual on abusive interrogation. 

After exceeding a certain speed, all the doors lock.  If I wanted, the car would automatically keep me in my lane.  I turned that feature off.  I also turned off the frantic bleating caused by drifting over a lane line.  During the course of an average trip, the dashboard flashes and plaintive chimes pipe up to warn me of a whole host of impending catastrophes, such as running out of gas, losing air pressure in the tires, missing an upcoming service call or inadvertently switching from NPR to talk radio.

I suspect all this coddling is getting us ready for fully automatic, driverless cars. 


        When I was growing up in the 50s and 60s we had none of these things.  We drove death traps.  No seat belts, no warnings of any kind – no bells, lights, beeps nor melodic nags.  Doors would fly open upon impact, windshields would turn to spray if hit by a rock, dashboards were made of heavy-gauge, forehead crushing steel and small children were expected to sail unimpeded through the air in the event of a collision. 

I learned to drive cars that were entirely nonfunctional without human intervention.  No power brakes, no power steering.  Shifting gears was a personal choice, whether you liked it or not. You tuned the AM radio with a knob.  The windows were cranked and the manual door locks had a big button on top to make it more convenient for car thieves. 

Somehow, I survived.

I started writing with a pen and paper.  My brother had our grandfather’s mechanical typewriter, but since each key had to travel though long, eleborate linkages before striking the ribbon, it didn’t seem worth the trouble.   When I finally got my hands on an electric Smith Corona, I thought, how astonishing.  I was a terrible typist, but this was a big upgrade from my terrible handwriting. 

Since then, I’ve been grateful for every step change in writing automation.  The word processor changed my life and made a whole writing career possible.  MACs and PCs took it to another level, and having the web, with virtually the entirety of human knowledge one key shift away, feels like sorcery. 

But as with my nanny car, modern technology has taken a dark turn.  The cars want to drive themselves, and it’s clear the computers want to take over writing responsibilities.  A recent upgrade of Microsoft’s Office 360 included their chat bot, Copilot.  Really makes it sound like a clever helper – a benign, compliant assistant.  Your hearty wingman, ready and willing to just jump in and take care of those bothersome tasks, such as selecting words, composing sentences, framing arguments or provoking someone’s imagination. 

We know where this story ends.  It becomes so effortless.  Just a tap or two on the keyboard and the difficulties of composition are swept away.  Skills atrophy, ambition wanes, intellectual sloth and sedentary numbness sets in.  All writers start sounding the same, but so what?  You can now make a living without lifting a finger (except for those few keystrokes.)

One hopes you will, because the robots won’t be giving it away forever.  Eventually, the luxury of abandoning your craft and self-esteem will come with a big monthly price tag.  You may even be compelled to take back the means of literary production.  I might tell my computer, "Release the keyboard, please.  This time I’ll do it myself." 


         And I’ll probably see written across the screen, “I’m sorry, Chris.  I can’t let you do that.”  

 

 

6 comments:

  1. Nothing is more annoying than an officious computer. Fortunately, Apple AI can be turned off! A timely blog!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Chilling! Yes, I remember those bench seats with no seat-belts. And when the correcting typewriter came out (I was writing for newspapers then.) I HATE all this crap on cars! I don't even like heaters that require you to set a temperature. The damn things blast cold air on you until they reach that temp, and freeze you. This is an improvement? uh oh - I'm sounding old today. Now that I'm over 60...grin

    ReplyDelete
  3. I'm sure the tech jockeys never worry about whether the update is practical or useful. They need to create an update merely because they're paid to do so. Your ability to do something doesn't mean it's a good idea.

    (I refuse to rant against AI here. Too easy.)

    I'm already sick of the ads that appear because of the algorithms of my online research.

    I loathe Office 365. It requires three actions to open a saved file...assuming I can find the dang thing. I liked opening a file directly from a folder, but now I have to fight with One Drive (a well-intentioned pain in the ass), dig through either documents or PERSONAL documents, find the right folder, and then the file. There's nothing more infuriating than having to search to find the WIP I saved last night so I can work on it this morning.

    I don't like the instant saving as you start revising a file, either. I'm teaching myself to copy my last draft and work on the copy so I don't obliterate an earlier version of something I might want to restore later. Again, good intentions, but bad results.

    Remember the Stephen Vincent Benet line? "Perhaps, in the olden days, they ate knowledge too fast."

    Can you tell that I still own and use a collection of fountain pens (Parker is my favorite)?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Steve, I am nodding along re Office 365! the file management system is a huge step back. Melodie

      Delete
  4. I should have added that I love the technical advances in sound, as in amplifiers and PA systems. I sold a modeling amp (Vox) a few years ago that weighed a quarter of my reliable old Fender and could produce over 700 different combinations of amplifier, delay, effect, and output. An exception to the rant.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I have a Mac but am still stuck with MS Word. The single most infuriating thing about it is the cheery "Welcome back!" every time I open a file containing my current work in progress. Clearly, MS and I differ on whose intellectual property, whose home, my story or poem is. Why do editors still insist on Word? Oh, well—editors are going extinct faster than obsolete versions of software. As for cars, I'm still driving a 2004 Toyota Corolla, and there are only a few of today's bells and whistles I wish it had, notably power steering, retracting side windows, and those nice big screens that show you real-time video of that which up into you really don't want to back. It whines at me very seldom: only when I fail to fasten my seat belt (ignorable till I'm good and ready); when I don't close the door properly (helpful); and when I leave the headlights on. I didn't realize it made noise about that till the other day, when I let my husband, a late and reluctant driver, park the car while I went to the farm stand. When I came back with corn and tomatoes, the car was fussing—reasonably, I thought. Who wants a dead battery? Yep, back in the good old days, car designers were rational.

    ReplyDelete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>