Showing posts with label Chris Knopf. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Chris Knopf. Show all posts

16 November 2026

Tyger, tyger


           When I published my first novel, I knew nothing about crime writing, book marketing, publishing or the mystery community, even if there was such a thing.  My first move was to go to the late and lamented Black Orchid Bookshop in New York and talk to Bonnie Claeson, who squandered over an hour counseling me while hopeful customers lined up to actually buy some of Bonnie and Joe’s books.

            Her first piece of advice was to go to Bouchercon and hang out in the bar.  This, I thought, was something I knew how to do.  Thus I stumbled like a castaway on a remote shore into a vast, welcoming realm of erudition and bottomless generosity.  In addition to getting some words into print, this was the best thing about the whole experience.


            I went to Crime Bake last week, New England’s regional conference held up near Boston.  I love this conference for all the reasons shared by the commentators and panelists.  It’s small, intimate, embracing and committed to serving the interests of writers at every level of the pursuit. 

            

            As we all agreed, you learn something valuable every time you go, and the pearl of wisdom I brought home is that no one involved in this world knows anything.  To put this in context, the screenwriter William Goldman notoriously said the same thing about Hollywood.  “Nobody knows anything.”  What’s missing from this is the rest of his quote: “Not one person in the entire motion picture field knows for a certainty what's going to work. Every time out it's a guess and, if you're lucky, an educated one.”

            

            In the past, it might have been possible for someone in the movie or publishing business to have captured at least a modest percentage of what is knowable.  There were certain rhythms and norms, a conventional process with intimations of predictability.  But after two decades of economic upheaval, lunatic politics, plagues and digital dismemberment of established institutions, all bets are apparently off.


           So I’ve come full circle.  I now know a container ship volume of information about this endeavor that I didn’t know before, and it’s worth just about as much as the air in the pockets of my jeans before I throw them in the wash.

            That is, if practicality was the only measure.  I once picked up another bit of wisdom from an advertising creative director, as unlikely a source as you can conceive.  He said, “The only things that matter in life are the people you love and the experiences you have.” By that calculation, my life is way ahead on the deal, and my association with the crime writing community, and all the contrary characters who inhabit it, is a major contributor.


            A stockbroker friend of mine tells me that the one circumstance Wall Street loathes more than any other is uncertainty.  It’s fitting that the people at the center of the planet’s greatest concentration of wealth revere certainty, a commodity that is virtually non-existent.  A supply and demand ratio that calculates to about zero to 100%.     

           

            It’s William Blake’s fearful symmetry.  Innocence is the state of certainty, uncertainty the price of experience.  If you’re lucky, you can get comfortable with what is basically the human condition.  The writing life, as it’s presently configured, may then be the best of all possible worlds. 

02 November 2026

The eternal sunshine of the perfect printed circuit


            Steve Jobs famously designed the inside of Apple computers to exacting aesthetic standards, even if repair technicians and recyclers were the only people who could relish the results. 

Most agree Jobs was a genius, and many also think he was nuts.  These afflictions often accompany each other, though I appreciate his impulse.   There’s a principle in sailing called good seamanship.  Examples might include coiling your dock lines in a neat circular fashion rather than simply draping them over a cleat.  Checking your position as you pass

through a channel you’ve traversed a thousand times.  Identifying yourself by the name of your craft, even when radioing a mate across the bay to come have a beer. None of these things are entirely necessary in the moment, but the ancient principle is to make proper practice a habit for those times when the mundane turns unexpectedly lethal.  Reflexively taking care of the little things extrapolates up into the significant; it becomes second nature, more a mood state than a procedure.

It seems there are a number of people for whom this is all too much bother.  It’s not the quality of the performance, they feel, only the end result.  I remember working around computer programmers who’d describe a string of code as elegant.  You could write an application that worked fine every time, but would be a tangled mess to the knowledgeable observer.  Or you could arrive there in a way that enlightened coders would find aesthetically pleasing.  My heart lies with the latter, if for no other reason than their applications would be more robust and adaptable to subsequent development.  And ultimately, far less expensive when fit into a massive project.

As an editor, I suspected any writer who disliked copyediting, or resisted fact checks.  It betrayed a recklessness of mind that put in doubt their broader artistic decisions.  Would that plot complication been solved with greater effort, would that character been better rendered with more respect for polish and precision?

        There are plenty of bestselling novelists whose work I’d describe as sloppy.  Often not with their first book, but as a series evolves, you get the feeling they aren’t really trying as hard.  The logic of these writers, and their editors and publishers, must be that if the books are selling, less care is required.  That might be true if your only criteria involves Book Scan.  There’s a market for poor quality, if a casual survey of your local Walmart is any guide, but for people like me, a well-crafted piece of fiction and a sturdy toaster elicits the same loyalty and regard.

A popular complaint is that quality just ain’t what it used to be.  Planned obsolescence is definitely a pervasive trend, though the big things, like cars and houses, are far better made now than they were when I was growing up.  Other important categories, such as power tools and crime novels, tend to ebb and flow.  The principal influence seems to be cultural disposition.  Poor quality appears to seep in when people are too pre-occupied to notice the decline, and then rally when a brand or genre starts securing appellationas like “cheap crap.”              

Mid-century pulp fiction has taken on a certain reverence by those who consider the form more authentic, unfairly denigrated in its time.  I doubt these admirers have read much of the real thing, since the product’s utility as actual pulp probably exceeded its literary merit.  I read a lot of it as a young person in search of elusive salacious content, without being particularly enriched or injured in the process.  Today, the odds are much better that any random mystery picked off the shelves will deliver a passing entertainment without the pleasure of atrocious plot structure and ersazt protagonists.

My favorite crime novels (also my favorite novels over all) were written a while ago, though I blame that more on my reading habits – and the moments in my life when these books caught my attention – than any deterioration of the form.  Getting a novel published these days is hardly a cakewalk, and those still achieving the task are closer to Steve Jobs than Mickey Spillaine.



19 October 2026

Anyone up for horseshoes and hand grenades?


When something is called a simple truth, it isn’t always a contradiction in terms.  Some truths are simple.  If you jump from the top of a mature oak tree without a means for arresting the fall, you will hit the ground.  Irrefutable. However, the underlying mechanism involved in this event is gravity, and there is nothing simple about a fundamental force of nature. Ask any physicist.

I’ll go out on a limb of that oak tree and propose there is no truth that is simple, for the simple reason that a truth itself is nearly impossible to establish absolutely in all its particulars for every observer assembled for the task.

I’ll creep further out on the limb, testing its tethering to the trunk, and propose that mystery stories, in all their dazzling variety and genre distorting forms, are all essentially about people seeking the truth, in competition with other people and circumstances aligned in opposition.

Truth has always been under threat, yet today is a time of particular advantage for the powers of concealment and obfuscation.  There is a cultural trend of people “speaking their truth.”  This is a triumph of solipsism, since it affords deference to the notion that everyone’s version of reality is equally valid.  It’s also in direct contravention of Daniel Patrick Monihan’s maxim that “Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.”  If one abandons Moynihan’s proscription, then there’s really no point in trying to understand anything.  In such a world, we would have no use for people like Sam Spade or V.I. Warshawski. 

I spent many years in close enough proximity to the media, often thoroughly involved in the matter being reported upon.  In all these cases, I never observed the story to be 100% accurate.  And none of these slight variations (some not so slight) would I attribute to malicious intent.  The principal culprit was time.  It just wasn’t possible for any reporter, editor or factchecker to pin down every nuance and particular with total precision in the time required to get the story written/published/distributed.   The majority of these imperfections were incidental, though not all.  Journalism has its share of sloppy performers, but by and large, they strive for an accurate and dispassionate recording.

Still, biases have a way of creeping in.  This is always true for everybody.  They’re often manifest in how information is interpreted.  One of the wonders of language, and the cognitive process overall, is the bounty of ways one can express any given thought or observation.  Within these multitudes, there’s little chance that something can be the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth.

What can be agreed upon is that everyone try to get close.  For this endeavor to work, we rely heavily on cynics, skeptics and imperturbable analytics.  Their counterparties are those committed to deceit, duplicity and guile, people actively striving to obscure the truth.  These folks are the bread and butter of the genre we celebrate, and thus indispensable.  What’s more interesting to me, however, are those who have decided the truth is their truth, a conclusion arrived at usually through a tortured, circuitous psychological voyage. 

They don’t have to be patently delusional.  There are plenty of historical heroes who simply understood something the rest of humanity considered absurd.  Though sometimes they are, they just don’t know it.  When this condition inhabits a brilliant or powerful mind, or a collective of capable people, things get really interesting. 

The action and adventure in the mystery genre are fun, though the appeal wanes over time.  What endures for me is the effort involved in uncovering the truth, however approximate it might be.  This dynamic achieves its fullest expression with the unreliable narrator, though any narrator’s reliability is also suspect for the reasons outlined above.  My favorite books are those that relish ambiguity and uncertainty while still managing to arrive at a satisfying conclusion. 

We know that massive social and political movements can be premised on monstruous untruths.  It’s unsettling to contemplate.  At least we have mysteries and their adjacent narratives, where in one messy entanglement someone was able to get close to something resembling a true thing.

05 October 2026

Oops


 

Mistakes, I’ve made few, but then again, too many to mention.  And more, much more than this, I did it any way I could figure out. 

            When people ask me how I’m able to make a certain piece of wood working, the only honest answer is, “A series of mistakes, randomly interrupted by moments of good fortune.”   I think the only difference between a person who succeeds at a craft, and one who doesn’t, is


the willingness to try.  Failure is not an option, it’s inevitable.  A completed project is the result of winnowing the number of mistakes down to a tolerable, and amendable, few.  Thus, making mistakes is not as important as knowing how to reorganize the flaws. 

            For this, the most important ingredient is humility.  When it comes to craft, we are all born sinners.  Accepting this is the road to endurance and faith that persistence, seasoned by patience and presence of mind, will see you through. 

            Some mistakes achieve an unexpected good.  We’ve heard about Velcro, Post-it notes and microwave ovens, but I have experienced a number of occasions when a colossal blunder resulted in a far better outcome.  This usually happens when I’ve made my intended effect impossible, so I’m forced to redesign the whole thing, turning a repair into a pleasing improvisation.     

Architects have known about this for a long time, probably because buildings are so big and take so long to put together that learning how to glorify a goof was an important strategy.   

            Not unlike building a novel.  I’m sure this is how many of you write.  Perhaps it’s the only way to write anything halfway decent. Anne Lamott’s shitty first draft is actually an exercise in dispensing thousands of mistakes that call for ingenious corrections.  Our most inventive writers are probably people who generate mistakes at scale, writing themselves out of one pitfall after another.

           

            The Grand Master of fortuitous mistakes is nature herself.  For every living thing, reproductive success is a numbers game.  The reason an individual produces far more eggs or sperm than needed to complete the transaction is it increases the odds for an acceptable match.  A byproduct of these multitudes is that little errors creep into the genetic scheme. It’s regrettable that the word “mutation” has a vaguely negative connotation.  Truth is, without mutation, we wouldn’t have evolution, since natural selection needs a toolbox of mis-made parts from which to select the preferred attribute for continued survival.   

If you really want to go large on the value of error, whatever existed before the Big Bang contained tiny quantum fluctuations, deviations from the norm.  This meant the universe didn’t start off perfectly configured, but instead, what cosmologists charmingly describe as slightly lumpy.  This meant that when expansion created the universe we ended up with galaxies, stars, and planets, one of which is our current residence.

            This is what I’d call a happy accident. 

            I’ve recently mentioned the delusion of perfectionism.  Nothing is perfect, and if it was, it wouldn’t do us much good.  It would just sit there in a smooth slab of static nothingness.  It wouldn’t grow, change, evolve or adapt.  This doesn’t mean there’s no point in trying to make things better. You just can’t make them perfect, and neither should you try.   

            Say what you will about the advanced technology we live with today, it mostly works.  It’s all pretty much based on quantum mechanics, which everyone applies, though no one really understands.   If you could boil down the unfathomable complexity of quantum theory, the remaining nugget would be probability.  Probably.  Outcomes are not predetermined, but rather the consequence of infinite, unknowable and evanescent interactions.  Heisenberg proved that “here and now” is ultimately an approximation. 


            This wouldn’t happen in a perfect world, but lucky for us, irregularity and imprecision makes the whole thing operational.  It’s been built into the system since the first nanosecond.  You might regret a mistake, but there’s no shame in it.  So have at it.  That’s why we have copy editors, imperfect as they are.   

21 September 2026

Pencils down


             Among the common laments of struggling writers is the problem of getting started.  Writing that first sentence, paragraph, chapter.  Personally, I like that part.  If all I had to do was start a project, my batting average would soar.  The difficulty for me is starting something good.  That’s a whole n’other kettle of fish.  And a consistent ravager of averages.

            There’s an opposite problem, which is knowing when to stop.  Both these issues are

dealt with by Issac Newton, who basically said getting something moving takes some effort, though stopping it can be even harder, or actually impossible, without the intervention of an opposing force. 

            Technically, the best treatment for this affliction is to have thought out the structure of your book in advance.  If you have a beginning, a middle and an end, presumably you’ll know when it’s time to stop.  This gets us into the tiresome debate over who’s a pantser and who’s an outliner.  If you believe the beleaguered panelists at a writers conference, we’re either one or the other.  Of course, the truth is usually somewhere in the middle, though when it comes to wrapping up a mystery novel, it’s pretty helpful to have a destination in mind as you’re writing along. 

Another trope of the writing commentariat is E.L. Doctrow’s bit, "Writing is like driving at night in the fog. You can only see as far as your headlights, but you can make the whole trip that way.”  That’s a lovely bit of poetry, but the most likely outcome of this approach is hitting a tree, or running over your next-door neighbor.  Employing a purely Doctrowian strategy, you might find yourself driving from Oxford, Mississippi to the Upper Peninsula, and not have a clue about how to find your way back.  If all that driving is a stand-in for work product, that means you‘ll be throwing out a lot of pages, and this I find

inexcusably wasteful.   I’m more in Reed Farrel Coleman’s camp, who says something like, “I know how to get started, and where I want to end up, and then I figure out how to get there along the way.”

There are believable reports from the conference stage of writers who find their plots revealing themselves as they write, with the finale popping into view at just the right moment, that is, when they’ve reached about 100 thousand words and everything suddenly makes a lot of sense.  I know this happens, and for some, it’s the only way it can happen, but I suspect their genius lies in the subconscious, which has been ably managing navigation while the driver is at the wheel wearing out her pants.


Newton did stipulate that the force needed to arrest motion is external, but this needn‘t apply to automobiles (which have brakes) or disciplined, experienced writers itching to write “Finis”.  Though in support of Newton’s proviso, we also have editors, armed with book contracts, underpinned by production costs and sales forecasts. I worked for a publisher once, and I got to say, “We love your book.  Please cut forty pages.”  I think this always made for a better novel, and importantly, one we could afford to print. 


Have you ever had a big chunk of writing get gobbled up by the computer, and been forced to recreate it all from scratch?  And then somehow come across the original pages?  In my case, the reincarnated version was always better, though some nice bits were invariably lost.  I copy these down and squirrel them away for future use.    


This might give you the idea that you can always improve your book if you have the time to constantly fiddle.  Though there’s a subset of the sin of overwriting, which is over rewriting.  In woodworking and car mechanics, two pursuits that have a lot in common with banging out novels, this is called “Fixing it till it breaks.”  It’s the delusion of perfectionists that refining will always elevate the product, not knowing when they’ve crossed into

sabotaging the messiness that actually creates something fresh and notable.  Whether inflicted by a heavy-handed editor, or ones internal arbiter, it amounts to a crime against art. It's not just about when to stop, but how you do it.

By far my favorite form of ending is one that really isn’t.  The reader thinks he’s idling around in a denouement, when all of a sudden he’s back in the soup.  Or a final twist pulls it all into a more satisfying conclusion (e.g. Presumed Innocent, my personal crime writing GOAT.)  James Cameron, undoubtedly inspired by Rasputin, built about five climaxes into the original Terminator, which my young son at the time renamed The Determinedator.  This technique is a lot of fun, but not that easy to pull off without seeming contrived.  I admire the writers who do.


Our most recent terrier, who died having outlived all his successors, always looked like he was eager to get on to the next thing.  He didn’t know what it was, but he was sure it was going to be great.  He might have been possessed by eternal optimism or just some fundamental drive; it wasn’t exactly joy, but certainly the sublime fulfillment that comes from never being entirely fulfilled. 




 

 

 

 

 

 

07 September 2026

School Daze


As far as I can tell, I was admitted to Dickinson College, a small, scholastically rigorous institution in Pennsylvania, on the strength of my swimming prowess. Certainly not my academic record, which should have prompted an admissions scandal. I was tipped off when I found the college swim team in my dorm room soon after I arrived. There were no athletic scholarships offered at Dickinson, but the coaches had a cozy enough relationship with the gatekeepers that the occasional standout was snuck through (someone with better high school preparation would have written “was sneaked”).

It helped that my father was prepared to pay full boat, so I opted for a different college path, one mostly involving beer, cigarettes, procrastination and rock ‘n’ roll, none of which were on the curriculum, though individual excellence in these areas was rewarded by allowing you to return every year, provided the maintenance of a shaky C average.

      My basic impediment was the theory of school itself. I could never grasp the concept of sitting together with people my age at little desks all day while someone at the front of the room told us things. That alone would have tried my patience, but they required you to

regurgitate their words at some later time, with rather harsh penalties for imprecise recollection. Worse still, once liberated at the ring of a bell, we had to use precious TV-watching and horsing around time to recapitulate much of the day’s proceedings, and even add to the burden with supplemental labor. The whole thing seemed entirely medieval.

They hadn’t yet identified ADHD in the 50s and 60, but I had such a ferocious case that my parents had to resort to drugs to keep me still in kindergarten. Thus afflicted throughout my school career, I thought “isn’t realizing his potential” was my middle name. Though I did have an ace in the hole. As with many things in my young life, it was provided by my big brother, who was an excellent student, but also an omnivorous, indefatigable reader. He caught the habit from my mother, so our house was crammed stem to stern with books.

Since I did everything my brother did, I read every book I fell over, and then some. As compulsions go, this was a lucky one to succumb to. Unsupervised as it was, my pool of knowledge was quite deep in some areas, and barely a puddle in others. My subsequent test performances had lots of hills and valleys, which evened out to around, well, a shaky C average.

The psychological lesson for me was that information I read tended to stick, whereas anything delivered from the metaphorical pulpit sounded like Charlie Brown’s TV parents. This led more than one teacher to ask my mother why a student who aced the test on Ancient Greece (didn’t every kid devour Edith Hamilton?) could barely add and subtract (still largely true.)

Although my math SATs never rose above the statistical probability of correctly guessing at least some of the answers, I did okay on the English side of the house, maybe just well enough for Dickinson to retain its accreditation. I’m not sure how much I learned in public school, but there’s an awful lot of information available when you have access to your mother’s Book of the Month subscription.

Most relevant to this platform, my bibliophilia soon blossomed into full blown hypergraphia. This not only saved my scholastic bacon, it provided the template for my entire life. When things were looking dire, I could always write myself out of trouble. In college, there was nothing more exhilarating than the option of a term paper versus a final exam. Somewhere within those ivy walls, I’d heard some critics regarded form as important as content. This theory was sorely tested across a variety of disciplines, but I made it through.

My roommate not only shared my general strategy, he honed it to perfection. A professor wrote at the bottom of one of his papers: “You write well, which is good, since you have very little command of the material.” He clinched a B in Russian Literature by using the liner notes of the Dr. Zhivago movie soundtrack as his sole reference. This is the stuff of greatness.

Since so little time was committed to slaving over The Brothers Karamazov, or door-stop biology texts, we had ample in reserve for 8 ball, making midnight grinder runs or destroying our hearing with electric guitars. Whatever was left on the schedule for actually writing those papers was usually reserved for about ten hours before the deadline. This was also, for me, an invaluable life lesson.

      It wasn’t until my Creative Writing MFA program, when the focus was entirely on matters of interest to me, that I discovered the pleasing embrace of a classroom, stimulating professors and the novelty of academic achievement. Since I had to pay for it all out of my own pocket, that might have enhanced my focus. But I came to regret being such a lousy student and all the stuff I could have learned had I been paying attention. Among my screwball college friends there are a few lawyers and corporate executives, along with a stockbroker, CEO and Dean of the Boston Cathedral. There’s no evidence that a decent grade point average distracted from their attention to the extra-curricular.

Trinity College once asked a cross-section of professionals to come speak to their students about proper career preparation. I was the designated advertising copywriter.

“First,” I told them, “don’t even buy the textbooks until about halfway through the semester. Take a passing glance when you get a chance, in case your parents come to visit and ask what you’re studying. On the night before your paper is due, get some pizza and sample the keg in the dorm basement, play a lot of pool, or basketball, if that’s your preference, until everyone’s gone to bed, then slip page one into the typewriter. Think desperately of something to write that will sound even remotely persuasive. Then you have to actually write something down, if you can stay awake.

“If you pass, they won’t kick you out, and you’re able to preserve your lifestyle (and in my case, stay out of the draft.) This is the life of a copywriter. Working with scant information, often exhausted, forced to produce a compelling argument under extreme pressure in a very short amount of time. Oh, and the stakes are pretty high. Just ask your kids, if you’re lucky enough to have them.”

They never asked me back. Don’t know why.

24 August 2026

As time goes by


I made the mistake of going back to read some of my favorite hard science fiction novels, most of which had been published in the late 20th century.  Brilliant, inventive works as they are, the writers got some of the science wrong.  Not their fault, the updated information had yet to be discovered.  Sadly, some of the undergirding plot lines depended on these false predictions, which caused the books to fall apart faster than a reflecting pool renovation.

The dangers of anachronisms lurk within literature as a whole, though not usually with the dire consequences of forecasting an event that hasn’t yet taken place.  Much of the absurd quibbling over the Odessey movie revolves around controversial moral and social updates, though the basic scaffolding remains intact and easily accessible by our tender 21st century sensibilities. This is largely true of most of the historical novels I’ve read, mysteries and otherwise, a credit to the authors’ disciplined research.   

(A shout-out here to Jim Benn’s Billy Boyle WWII mysteries, focusing on an era I’ve taken an interest in, which never disappoint, or have me reaching for Wikipedia.)    

When the question arises at writers conferences on how to deal with the assault of advanced technology, in particular the ease with which you can now instantly harvest information about nearly everything without leaving your parents’ basement, some authors breezily say they just set their books before all that happened. 

However, if you chose to start the timeline even a couple decades in the past, you better be on your toes.  You might say, yeah, but I was there!  To which I’d reply, how’s that long term memory working?  Brain scientists will tell you not as good as you think.  Never has the term “trust but verify” been more true.  Nor the value of border collie-like fact checkers of greater value.

One thing’s for sure.  It’s a lot more interesting to follow Phillip Marlowe – as he drives around in his jalopy, intrudes on people’s privacy, drops dimes into payphones and hectors reliable sources in the LAPD or Los Angeles Times – then to describe a lonely guy tapping out commands to Gemini or ChatGPT.

            If there ever was an existential threat to the business of murder mysteries, this is it.  Having your hero hook up with a tech nerd helps – I’ve got one myself – though this has now become such a tired trope, I wish I hadn’t succumbed to the temptation.  On some TV shows, the humans in the operation are reduced to performing the few tasks left to them, such as punching bad guys in the face, or appreciating a nice sunset.  It’s worse when equally clever geeks are on either side of the good vs. evil divide, trying to out-tech each other.  Why not just have Hera and Athena duke it out with lightning bolts, like they did in the old days?  At least the pretense of human agency is not an issue. 

Science fiction, ever resilient despite the risks, has some solutions.  In one book, alien bacteria have eaten all the insulation around electronic conductors, collapsing the whole edifice.  In another, there’s a super cyberintellience, but it turns out it likes to lie, just for fun.  Alien lifeforms are often good for mixing it up, especially when the author has the sense to grace the other worlders with entirely different sets of urges and motivations.   

Chaos Theory (interestingly named, since it actually delineates order within seemingly chaotic dynamic systems) features the state of phase transition, such as the frenzied condition of liquid H2O right before it turns into steam.  We’re living in such a thing ourselves, caught between past experience and the hurtling uncertainties of the future.

             A friend of mine, a retired stockbroker, has a healthy catalog of aphorisms that helped guide his career.  One of my favorites is, “People have a tendency to extrapolate current circumstances indefinitely into the future.”  Science would agree this is entirely fallacious, since the only constant in the universe is that everything has a cycle, that current circumstances will always change, you just don’t know exactly how.  There is no Steady State, even though Einstein once tried to prove there was, an effort he later abandoned, somewhat sheepishly. 

Perhaps the most reliable constant informing literature is that people are infinitely complex, and that love, vulnerability and death play havoc with every being’s emotional and intellectual composition.  The human factors may vary with the sociology of the era, but the fundamental things apply.

Maybe not forever, but for now, that’s good enough. 

10 August 2026

It’s a poor craftsman who blames his tools


             I mostly concur with this proverb, though I have had tools come apart in the middle of a cut, all on their own, resulting in marred work and much cursing, mostly directed at the tool’s manufacturer.  Though the villain is nearly always the operator, in whose charge proper tool maintenance justly resides.

            I started trying to write in a time when the only available tools involved ballpoint pens and mechanical typewriters.  For me, the typewriters were non-starters.  Too clunky and hard to use, the travel distance from key to paper amounting to several inches of quarrelsome

springs and levers.  The pen, in this case, was mightier, though the handwriting was abysmal, assuring that my works in progress were basically unreadable by anyone but myself until I succumbed to a typewriter for the final draft.

            Word processors saved my life and finger joints and I’ve never looked back.  Only now there's a new tool widely available, artificial intelligence, though I submit that this isn’t a handy assistant, but rather a fraud, pure and simple, and unworthy of any other designation.

            

                When I wanted to buy my first electric guitar, my father asked me if it played the music for you.  It took me a moment to figure out what he was saying, but quaintly, he actually thought that maybe the electronics industry had leaped ahead about sixty years and invented a device that rescued the musician from the inconvenience of learning to play music.  This would have been quite a technical achievement for the time, but I doubt it would have resulted in creating The Beatles’ oeuvre, much less anything else people would be interested in listening to.

           

                So why would you hire a robot to do your writing for you?  Well, I guess if you don’t know how to write, and have no interest in doing so, AI is some sort of blessing.  It’s no accident that Kurt Vonnegut called his anti-automation novel Player Piano.   There’s nothing wrong about having an upright piano in the living room to entertain guests with Scott Joplin and Gilbert and Sullivan before acquiring the luxury of vinyl and cherry-veneered stereo consoles.  But no one but the fully deranged or duplicitous ever claimed to be performing the works themselves.

            

               The promise of AI is that you can have your exposition scored and performed by someone else, and then easily foist it off as your own composition.  In my old-fashioned brain, this is merely deception, forgery, plagiarism, theft of intellectual property and the kind of plain old cheating that used to get you heaved out of whatever legitimate pursuit you’d be engaged in.

        

              I don’t think the subject is even worthy of debate, though I’ll try anyway.

           

               The Luddites famously got all out of sorts when machinery began to replace manual craft.  I’d like to get one of these guys in my wood shop, show him a table saw, drill press, dove tail jig, plunge router and a stack of raw wood and tell him to whip up a Federal-style highboy.  I bet, like my father, he’d learn that these modern machines don’t do any of the work without human intervention.  My son is an expert with the type of hand tools favored by the Luddites, but can also make mind-blowingly intricate wooden objects with laser cutters and CNC milling machines.  The designs still come out of his head, and the computer applications only know how to do what he’s programmed them to do.  They are tools, and if you think they make the art easy, just give it a try.

            I imagine someone could enlist AI to render work in his style, but the product would be akin to the slop anyone could crank out by asking Chat GPT to write a Hemingway short story.     

            There’s a gigantic qualitative difference between using a machine to make something and having the machine make it all by itself.  I have great admiration for anyone who can make a perfect dove tail joint by hand, but I just don’t see the point in spending a month doing something I can do pull off in an afternoon with a jig and a couple routers.  One could also spend a few years designing and manufacturing a machine that can make a thousand dove tail joints in that same afternoon.  But unless I have a furniture factory, why bother?

            

             Before straining the analogy past the breaking point, it’s important to note that writing isn’t manufacturing.  It’s a craft and an art, and in its fullest realization, it’s creation.  You can’t hand this over to a robot and expect to come out of the experience whole.  Even if no one notices, you’ve sold a crucial part of yourself down the river.