13 July 2020

It Is What It Is... Or Is It?


Special treat today.  I first met Craig Faustus Buck at Bouchercon in Long Beach in 2014, when we shared a panel on short stories, but my fondest memories come from a year later when we were partners at the speed dating session at Bcon in Raleigh.  We went from table to table of readers, each getting three minutes to explain the wonders of our books.  By the end it was so routine that I suggested we plug each others' books instead.  He wisely deferred.

Craig has been nominated for numerous awards (winning some) for his neo-noir novel Go Down Hard, as well as his short stories, many of which are available for free at CraigFaustusBuck.com  He is also a screenwriter whose credits include an Oscar nomination and the famous episode where The Incredible Hulk drops acid. He says he takes great pride in his pit mastery and sucks at poker.

— Robert Lopresti


It Is What It Is… Or Is It?
by Craig Faustus Buck

Take a gun. Put in the hands of a markswoman in a biathlon. It is what it is… a piece of sporting equipment. Put that same gun in the hands of a ten-year-old at school during recess. It is what it is… a potential tragedy. Put that same gun in the hands of a cop… it is what it is, depending on whether you're black or white, whether he's honest or dirty, whether he's drunk or sober, whether he's calm or enraged, you get the picture. In real life, very few things are what they are. Instead, almost every object has the potential to be something different to different people or from different points of view.

The phrase "it is what it is" was first seen in print in 1949 when a Nebraska newspaper used it to describe the difficulty of pioneer life. USA Today crowned it the #1 cliché of 2004. These days it is as ubiquitous as Starbucks. And that's unfortunate.

The phrase is what psychologists call a "thought-terminating cliché" (also known as a semantic stop-sign, a thought-stopper, and bumper sticker logic). It is a way to end discussion without making a point, to solve a problem by abdicating responsibility. It implies that nothing can be done, that what ever "it is" is inevitable. It is an iron hand squeezing the windpipe of further thought.

To a writer, however, the phrase can be a terrific wakeup call.

Whenever I find myself thinking "it is what it is" about what I'm writing, I know it's time to take the bull by the horns and a find a way to turn "it" on its head so that what it is becomes something my reader isn't expecting. This could be a plot twist, a character oddity, an emotional outburst, or any number of other doodads from the writer's toolkit. If I were to take things for granted and simply describe them without exploring their potential, I'd wind up writing the sort of bland exposition that my poor readers would have to clean off their shoes after I've made them step in it. Surprises delight readers and, by definition, cannot exist if plot lines, emotional arcs or characters simply are what they are.

For example, in my short story "Honeymoon Sweet" (Bouchercon anthology, 2014), I started out with:

For a sweet house, right on Santa Monica Beach, it was unbelievably easy to break into. Mickey found a window he could open with a putty knife, so the double-locked doors were a joke. And Lana disabled the alarm within the forty-five-second grace period before it would have triggered. They were in and no one knew.

I thought it was a nice way to open a story. The first line was promising. But the rest of the paragraph seemed to telegraph that this was just another caper. It was saying "it is what it is" instead of "it won't be what it seems." So I added:

What a great way to kick off the honeymoon.

All of a sudden the stage was set. The reader knew to expect the unexpected and, as a bonus, there would be an emotional component to the story. As a seat-of-the-pants writer, the addition also sent me in a direction I wasn't expecting, which made the writing infinitely more fun, and the story more fulfilling to me and, hopefully, to readers.

While "it is what it is" is literally stating the obvious (a writer's felony) and figuratively avoiding creative solutions (a writer's suicide), it can also be like one of those signs on highway offramps that warn "Wrong Way" when you consider taking that path. Heed the warning while you're still in your first draft. Because if you don't, well, it is what it is.

Stay safe,
— Craig

16 comments:

O'Neil De Noux said...

Good post. You're right ... heed the warning.

janice law said...

A terrific story opening! Thanks for stopping by.

Eve Fisher said...

Interesting honeymoon - I'd certainly read on. Thanks for joining us.

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks O'Neil, Janice and Eve. I'm always happy at Sleuthsayers. Am an inveterate purveyer of bumper sticker logic.

Jacqueline Seewald said...

Good advice! Your way draws the reader into the story.

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks, Jacqueline.

Jennifer J. Chow said...

Great post, Craig! I also loved learning about the historical background.

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks, Jennifer! It was fascinating to research. I always thought it was a much more modern phrase.

John Floyd said...

Great column, Craig! Good to have you here at SS. Take care!

Jan Christensen said...

Great post, Craig. An excellent reminder to put in the unexpected, the sooner, the better, and often. Like you, I write without an outline, and I enjoy surprising myself, hoping the reader will also be surprised.

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks John and Jan, great to hear from you both. Stay safe.

Elizabeth Zelvin said...

Ohhh. So THAT'S what's wrong with it! Thanks, Craig. :)

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks for reading, Elizabeth. Stay safe.

Harley said...

Wonderful, Craig! As a member of your writers group (btw, I never know if that should be writer’s, writers’ or plain old writers) I can attest to the fact that even your early drafts rarely “are what they are.” This blog explains why I find your noir so ... happy!

Craig Faustus Buck said...

Thanks, Harley. See you on Zoom.

Bonnie MacBird said...

Terrific points made here, Craig! I agree with Harley who commented earlier, it's what makes your work always a pleasure, and always a surprise.