I will admit that I, too, thought "The master has failed more times than the beginner has even attempted" was a Chinese proverb. Apparently not – most sources give Stephen McCranie, the comic book artist, credit. Regardless, it's my favorite aphorism and at this point I've probably said it more times than McCranie.
Because I fail a lot.
When I was young, I dreamed of being a lab researcher, but a stint at the National Institutes of Health put paid to that.
I still cringe when I think of the way chimpanzees were housed in tiny crates in the labs, how experiments were scrapped and living animals "sacrificed" by the scores because the scientists wanted to attend a wedding or hit the slopes.
It would have been a dream job for some – I reported directly to two Nobel Laureates. But I was miserable and gave up my plans for a career in science.
I modeled for a time and I was terrible at it. I had the height but not the รฉlan. I couldn't wear contact lenses so I had to whip my thick glasses on and off continually for pictures. I was clumsy in heels and once stepped right off a runway. Oops.
Acting was fun and I was good at it. So were a thousand other young actors with thicker hides than mine. Failed again.
I was doing pretty well as a soft-news journalist. I wrote a snarky and very popular column for Buzz, then a hot new magazine billed as "the talk of Los Angeles." I covered parties for InStyle and scandals for Redbook and the other "seven sisters" magazines.
Then I stepped away for a hot minute to have a baby and when I was ready to get back to work, the editors who had once supplied me with a steady stream of assignments had moved on. Nobody knew my name. Failed again.
My first novel was a chapter book for kids published by Bantam Skylark. The acquiring editor left the house before Dog Magic came out. Death knell. Same for my next two books, one horror and one suspense, both from a major house, and both "orphaned" before their debuts.
When a book is orphaned, there's no one at the publishing house to schmooze buyers at book fairs, treat drinks, and fight for you to get reviews. They save those efforts for their own discoveries, for understandable reasons. The results were predictable. There's that F word again.
I abandoned writing and decided to become a teacher. With no credential and no training, I landed a job at at a yeshiva, then segued that into a spot at a top independent school. Then another. After classes, I worked on a young adult novel I called Big and Bad and How I Got My Life! Back. That book was so damned good. I knew it would be a hit and I would join the ranks of superstar YA authors John Greene and Laurie Halse Anderson. I sent Big and Bad off to one publisher, who rejected it. Then I tossed it in a drawer and sulked for the next fourteen years. Not kidding.
One day I came across the manuscript on my hard drive, read it, and liked it a lot. I polished it up and shipped it off to a contest sponsored by Texas Review Press. Big and Bad came in second but they published it anyway, and the following year it won the Paterson Prize for Books for Young People. Big and Bad got a rave review in School Library Journal, which is the go-to nearly all schools and libraries consult when stocking their shelves. Shoulda been a contender - but that dang pandemic thing got in the way. Since you're all writers, I don't need to explain. No stock, no ship, no shelf, no sale.
So. Teaching. I love teaching and I love kids. I don't love schools and I can barely abide administrators. I've been fired from more schools than some states have in their school system. In fact I've been fired from almost every job I've ever held, although a couple of times I managed to squeak out a quick I quit before they could lower the axe.
So you're picking up a theme here, right? Failure after failure, sometimes my fault, sometimes just the way the cards were dealt. But every single failure taught me something. Lots of things, actually, and I use all of those things in writing fiction and poetry.
When I was a kid, my sister and I would fight over Ellery Queen and Alfred Hitchcock when they arrived each month. (Yeah, it was a long time ago - they were both still monthlies!) I can truly claim to be a life-long fan, but it didn't occur to me to try selling a story to Ellery Queen until I was sixty years old. Sixty! According to Guardian Life Insurance, the average American retires at sixty-two - and here I was trying something brand-spanking new. Scary!
Janet Hutchings rejected my story, of course - it was all wrong for Ellery Queen. She rejected the next one, too, but then she bought Krikon the Ghoul Hunter, and then a whole bunch more.
My stories from Ellery Queen have been recorded in podcasts, nominated for awards, given prizes, published as a collection, and selected for "Best Ofs." And of course I publish elsewhere, too - sometimes in the strangest places. I've published a poem in Fungi Magazine (yes, all about mushrooms!) and a story I wrote for The Saturday Evening Post is part of the national high school curriculum of Fiji. Yep. The island nation. Don't ask. I'm just grateful.
It's a crazy writing life, this one. Some mystery writers my age have been publishing short stories for fifty years, not seven years. I'm kind of a newbie. My heart still beats fast when Jackie Sherbow tells me she'll take a story for EQMM, or when an editor asks me to write a story for an anthology, or a literary journal picks up a poem, or a university professor tells me he's teaching one of my poems or stories. I still sulk when a piece gets turned down, and I have cried more than a few late-night tears over rejections from editors I thought adored me.
I'm still trying, and I'm still failing. I've failed a lot.
And I've succeeded a lot, too.
Because that's the only way to get anywhere in this world. Try, and fail. Then try and fail again. Because the master has failed more times than the beginner has even attempted.


.jpg)



Ah, another animal lover who opted out of biology. A loss, I am sure, to the profession, but clearly writing's gain!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Janice! It would not surprise Me to learn there are many of us!
DeleteI feel for you, Anna. Between 1972 and 2007, I taught high school English and did 100 productions in community theater. I also collected over 350 rejections for about 25 short stories and between five and ten novels (a couple were rewritten so much I think they count as separate books). I sold my first short story when I was 60. EQMM has rejected over 60 of my submissions, but about 45 of them sold somewhere else. A sale to EQMM is still on my bucket list.
ReplyDeleteAnd I started school in pre-dent, but couldn't handle physics because my algebra was so weak.
We are on the same trajectory, Steve!๐
DeleteYes! I'm thinking of that quote: "Ever try? Ever fail? No Matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." I have recently thought of myself as the 'fail better queen'. Even after 50 years in the biz (yes, I'm one of those - first publication at 18, 21 novels and 60 short stories, I still can't be sure the big mags will pick my stories, or the series I'm currently writing will go past 6 books. Every new project is a risk. I was on a panel with Linwood Barclay a few years ago and we were asked "Does it get harder or easier with each new novel?" We each said 'harder' at the same time! This is a great column, Anne.
ReplyDeleteThanks, Melodie! When I sold my first book my cousin excitedly asked me what kind of car I was going to buy with the advance. I told her a pink plastic one for my Barbie.๐
DeleteSorry that posted as anonymous – it's Anna!
DeleteWonderful post, Anna. You're telling my story—except for the modeling. I didn't have the ankles. Or rather, too much of the ankles. Not enough height. Too much frame. Too much butt. Too much nose. And no Nobel laureates, except for the one who went to college with my sister and with whose brother I went on an American Youth Hostels bike trip at age 15), who, a year or two after receiving the Nobel Prize, had his picture on the front page of the New York Times for being fired from his job at a major research institution because one of his mentees falsified research—thus demonstrating that even winning the Nobel Prize doesn't necessarily protect you from failure. As for editor stories, there was the guy at St Martin's who had the ms on his desk for two and a half years, finally read it and told me to rewrite it completely, turning the second protagonist into a sidekick, and when I did (greatly improving the novel), said, "I'm so sorry—I'm leaving publishing to go to law school." St Martin's did finally publish that first novel on my 64th birthday, and it's been downhill, like a ski slope with those bumps (or is it uphill, like Sisyphus?) ever since, till now, learning all the way. I knew exactly what I was doing when I turned down bad contracts to self-publish my new poetry book. And my latest story is about a reader, a guy I've known since I was 11. My book contains a poem about his 80th birthday party, which I attended. My Xmas morning started with a text from his wife, saying she'd bought the book as a surprise present for him, and ended with a text from him, saying he'd read "his" poem aloud to his assembled extended family at their Xmas dinner: "There was silence all around, and it took my breath away. There could not have been a better present." He added that they would be buying five more copies of my poetry book. Define "failure."
ReplyDeleteLove this comment, Liz! Especially “define failure.“ Success and failure feel like opposites, but they aren’t - often they are complementary working parts of the same process.
DeleteGreat blog piece. I’m not exactly where I wanted to be by this age, but this is a good reminder that, in many ways, life is just beginning. It can be easy to get caught up in the “highlight reel” that is today’s social media and compare my successes or failures to what I see on the screen, but this blog post is a sound reminder that folks I consider very successful like you have had their fair share of rejections, too. Thanks for being so candid in this piece.
ReplyDeleteWhat a lovely comment -thank you very much!
DeleteGreat post, Anna! I can relate. We've had a similar trajectory with a few different bits and pieces. The modelling stuff — started that when I was 17 and I too was a clumsy oaf and I once got fired by a German magazine for showing up with pimples. The horror! Whaddya gonna do? By the time I hit my 30s, I was out of that world and into writing. My earlier publications were all poetry and "literary" fiction. Twenty years ago, I never imagined that I'd turn away from that and jump into the mystery/crime world with all four paws. Makes me feel like a cat on my 3rd life :)
ReplyDeleteThank you for your openness. Your tenacity is magnificent! Congratulations on all the times you gotten right back up after a fall and the wonderful successes that came from that.
Thanks, Billie! We have a lot in common!
ReplyDeleteOh, I can relate as well, Anna. I've worked as a secretary, a clerk at a store straight out of Kevin Smith's "Clerks", making pizzas, more secretarial stuff, and so many other jobs. At night I wrote and tried and wrote and tried, and could paper a whole house with my rejection slips. I managed to get a few humorous essays in Dakota Outdoors and a few poems here and there. Finally sold my first mystery when I was 45, to AHMM. Greatest moment of my life. Tenacity will get you a lot of places! Never give up!
ReplyDelete45? You were just a kid!
DeleteBless you.
ReplyDeleteWow! You're a wonder, Anna. I identify with all the falling and getting back up which is the only way to deal with failure I have found - although that's not failure then. That is grit. Just what is needed from my perspective - that of an 82 year old.
ReplyDeleteThank you, Susan! You've had your share of success as a poet, too!
Delete