24 April 2022

Breaking It Down


As some of you already know, my story, "The Road to Hana," was one of six to be nominated for an Edgar in the Short Story Category. Plus, there's some of you who may have read my article in The First Two Pages after Art Taylor asked me to write an essay as part of his program to get essays from those short story authors who were nominated this year. So now for the rest of you, I'm going to break down some of my reasoning for the sentences I wrote for the beginning of my story.

The Background

My wife and I had vacationed on the Hawaiian island of Maui for two weeks in February for several years. No, we aren't rich. It's just that we learned how to do it on a lower budget. We got a special (return) rate at a small condo on the beach, rather than staying in an expensive resort area, cooked most of our own meals (it's a budget killer if you eat out a lot, unless you eat where the locals eat) and we found some of the little secrets of Maui. For instance, did you know that native Hawaiians  get a Kamaaina discount at many of the shops and stores? Seems my wife with her suntan at that time was often mistaken for Kamaaiana (local). And, did you know there's a writers open critique group that meets in an old stone church on the road leading upcountry from the old hippie town of Paia? You have to look hard for some of this stuff.

In any case, during our many stays, we traveled the road to Hana on the other side of the island several times, a couple of those times even going beyond Hana to other sites.

Photo by Jim Evans on Wikipedia
On one visit, while reading the local newspaper, I ran across an article about a young man who had smoked some of the petals of the local Trumpet Flower, a known hallucinogenic. The young man then made the decision to go deep water swimming. He was never seen again.

I was intrigued. He will never know it now, but that young man started the brainstorming for a story, even if it did take years before the story actually got written.


And now the opening sentences

There's only one road from Kahului's airport going over to the small town of Hana on the eastern side of the island.

This opening sets the place and tells the reader that the protagonist, or anyone else, going to or from the town of Hana only has one choice of roads to take if traveling by vehicle.

And then, the next line. This Hawaii highway has 59 bridges and 620 curves for the 52 miles it takes to get there. This sentence foreshadows that the road and its curves can be dangerous to drivers if those travelers are not careful. Call it atmosphere, call it background, call it setting, this is a situation where the topography of the land becomes an important part of the story and crucial to the plot, as the reader will soon realize.

I've got no idea who took the time to count the number of curves in the road. This emphasizes the curves and sharp turns to keep that image in the reader's mind for when our protagonist must travel that road, first to Hana and later back to the airport for his flight home.

Whoever he was, he must've been really bored that day and had nothing else to do. Fine by me, I was looking for boredom right about now. There's nothing like being shot on the job to make you want to stop the world and smell the roses, hell, smell any kind of flowers and thank your lucky stars the other guy wasn't a better shot. Okay, now the savvy reader knows the protagonist is some type of law enforcement who has come to the island paradise for peace and recovery from his injuries. Will he find it? A mystery reader already knows the answer to that and reads on to find out what happens next.

After more description of hairpin turns, old one-way cement bridges, deep jungle ravines on one side and steep drops to the ocean on the other, our protagonist notes: If you go off the edge here, you'd best be able to fly.

Later: It was at one of these quick turns reaching out towards the ocean where I saw flashing lights in late afternoon.

Our protagonist gets out of his rental car to check on the situation. Looked to me like two tow trucks were trying to winch a wrecked car out of the foaming surf and drag it up the slope. Also looked like a slumping body was seat-belted behind the steering wheel. Evidently, some poor schlub had tried to take a straight line where the asphalt took a bend.

Was this an accident or murder? The reader has suspicions and journeys on with our hero to find out alongside him as he slowly discovers what is going on.

So now, you tell me, did I do my job? Did the opening sentences draw you in? Is this a story you want to read? I know the opening worked well enough for the editor of Alfred Hitchcock Mystery Magazine to accept the story. 

I submitted it on 07/21/18. It was accepted on 09/29/19 and published in the May/June 2021 issue of AHMM. On 04/28/22 at the Edgar Awards Banquet in Manhattan, we will see if the story is good enough for an Edgar.

In the meantime, I, along with everyone else, will keep on writing. There is always next year and who knows which new story will get nominated and which author will win the Edgar. Maybe I'll get another chance at Ed… yeah, I've got this great idea for a story in mind about this…

20 comments:

  1. The opening works very well! Best of luck with the Edgars

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. The competition is really tough this time.

      Delete
  2. Congratulations with the nomination, R.T. I hope you'll have a great time in NYC. Best of luck!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you. As for a great time in NYC, my wife has already bought us tickets for a Broadway play.

      Delete
  3. I remember the story well. It was excellent, and I understand why it was nominated for an Edgars - best wishes with it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eve, I was just happy that Linda bought the story in the first place,

      Delete
  4. Excellent story. You worked the setting well. Good luck with the Edgar.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, this is one of those times that the setting made the story.

      Delete
  5. Best of luck at the Edgars. That's a really long journey, from submitting the story to finding out if you won, not counting the time it took you to write it!

    Did you see Pat Benatar there? She lives in Hana, part of the year anyway.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We did not run into Pat, but then we also did not run into Oprah who owns 63 acres near Hana. Nor did we see Kris Kristofferson or several other celebrities in that area. Willie Nelson owns Charlie's Bar in Paia. We've eaten there several times over the years, but sadly no sightings. Clint Eastwood has a house in Wailea. I've snorkeled that area, but never bumped into him.

      Delete
  6. I remember the opening lines vividly, along with the rest of the story. Good luck at the Edgars!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Susan, thanks for the well wishes. It's all up to the judges now. And, if I don't get to read my acceptance speech, I've already thanked my wife for being my First Reader.

      Delete
  7. Once again, congratulations, RT. Love that certificate!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. My wife was so excited when we got the certificate in the mail that she dragged me down to Hobby Lobby to immediately get a suitable frame. It's now on the study wall.

      Delete
  8. Enjoyed this, R.T. "TRtH" was a great story, and deserving of the honor!

    Have a good time in NYC!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. John, other than attending a play, we will probably revisit sites from past trips. Central Park where we watched scenes from a movie being made. Never did find out what movie the horse carriage and passengers went in. Up to the top of the Rock. A visit to the Russian Vodka Room for Baltika #3 beer. And.....

      Delete
  9. R.T., I hope to see you and your wife at the Dell party on Thursday afternoon.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And if David Dean shows up, then we three can have our photo taken like we did years ago.

      Delete
  10. Well written post about the origins of a great story. Good luck on your nomination.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Congratulations on winning the Edgar's Short Story award, R.T!

    ReplyDelete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>