In 1987, authorities investigated the death of a motorcyclist, John Powell. A toxicology report revealed cyanide in his system. Powell died at Drake Hospital (now the Drake Center, which is shutting down soon.) Several employees were interviewed. Suspicion fell upon an orderly, Donald Harvey. Soon, WCPO anchor Pat Minarcin dug into Harvey's history. It turned out he had been dismissed from Cincinnati's VA hospital for suspicious behavior. Before long, it became apparently several people might have died by Harvey's hand.
Harvey was born in Butler County, Ohio, in 1952, but raised near London, Kentucky, just north of the Tennessee border. He was abused as a child, which may or may not have played into his later crimes. However, it did not excuse them. After 37 admitted murders, courts tend to discount the insanity defense.
Harvey went to work for Marymount Hospital in 1970 at the age of 18. His first victim was 88 year old Logan Evans. Evans was a difficult patient whom Harvey smothered. When caught finally in 1987, Harvey claimed he was a mercy killer. Evans's death debunks that notion. Evans clearly had dementia. He was violent at times and even smeared feces on Harvey's face. Harvey retaliated by using a pillow and a plastic bag to smother him. By the time Harvey left Marymount in 1971, nine people died of what appeared to be natural causes only for Harvey to confess them sixteen years later to avoid the death penalty.
So how did he get away with it? Turning off patients' oxygen. Changing the medication in their IVs. In several cases, he smothered them.
Four years after leaving Marymount, Harvey had moved to Cincinnati, where he began working for the VA in 1975. The bulk of his murder spree happened here, and with the same tactics. Eventually, he got caught.
Not committing murder. He was fired for stealing body parts. Harvey had taken to performing occult rituals. Was that connected to his penchant for killing patients? The Satanic Panic of the 1980s would say yes, but Harvey started killing people long before his interest in the occult.
So naturally, Drake Hospital, now the Drake Center for Rehabilitation, hired him as an orderly. It proved to be Harvey's downfall. His final victim, a motorcyclist named John Powell, came to Drake in a coma after an accident. Powell died at Drake, and a pathologist grew suspicious and did a deeper dive on Powell's toxicology. He found cyanide. Police questioned employees and zeroed in on Harvey.
Enter Pat Minarcin, in the late 1980s, an anchor for Channel 9 WCPO. An employee at Drake voiced suspicions about Harvey to him. Minarcin did some digging. Soon, the extent of Harvey's crimes became apparent. After Minarcin's reporting, prosecutors confronted Harvey. How many people did he kill? Confess all of them, or they would go for the death penalty. Harvey admitted to thirty-seven murders but insisted he did it to end his victims' suffering. After some of the deaths were re-examined, the prosecutors stopped believing him. He was convicted of all 37 counts.
In prison, however, came to light he had possibly killed 87 people. By that point, he was in the Toledo Correctional Facility. In 2017, like Jeffrey Dahmer before him, he was murdered himself by a fellow inmate.

What a charming orderly. Any idea what drew the pathologist's suspicions?
ReplyDelete