30 December 2023

2023 in Review


  

Another year's almost done, and I'm posting an easy-to-write column today: a look back at the stories I've published in the past twelve months. It's a task that's occasionally fun and occasionally disappointing. Sometimes editors seem to welcome me into their publications with grins and open arms, and sometimes they kick me off their doorsteps and then throw my hat after me like a frisbee. As it turned out, this was a good year, writingwise--a little better than 2022, not quite as good as 2021--and I guess I can't complain.

Here are some observations about my 2023 literary output and thought processes:


January


- I had 57 short stories published this year, and have 34 more in my PENDING file (accepted but not yet published). The reason that pending number sounds high is that 16 of those have been accepted for a 2024 (or early 2025) collection of my "detective" stories. 

- I wrote 25 new stories in 2023, fewer than usual, but many of those were longer stories, so maybe my typing fingers didn't know the difference.

- For the first time ever, I had almost as many stories published in anthologies as in magazines, if you count markets like Crimeucopia and Two-Minute Mini-Mysteries as anthologies. I think the reason I had more stories in anthologies than usual--even though I didn't see as many open-submission antho calls as I used to--was that (1) several anthologies chose to publish some of my reprints and (2) a good many others were invitations to submit themed stories--and I try hard to say yes to those. I don't always, but I try.

- Far more of my stories in 2023 were firmly mystery/crime than any other genre. Specifically, five of the others were Westerns--I love 'em--and four were SF/fantasy. Two more were a combination of Western and fantasy (picture the movie Cowboys and Aliens--or at least the concept behind it). One was published in an anthology called, if you can believe it, Monster Fight at the O.K. Corral. That one was a LOT of fun to write!

- Most of my magazine stories appeared in seven markets: AHMM, Strand Magazine, Mystery Magazine, Woman's World, Sherlock Holmes Mystery Magazine, and Black Cat Weekly. Nothing unusual, there. But I had a story in every issue of the Strand this year, which was unusual.

- I had only three private-eye stories published in 2023, two of them in Michael Bracken-edited anthologies. (Eight more PI tales have been accepted and are awaiting publication.) Andrew McAleer and the late Paul Marks are the ones who got me started writing about private investigators, for a 2017 anthology called Coast to Coast: Private Eyes from Sea to Shining Sea, and Michael published my first magazine private-eye story, "Mustang Sally," in 2020's Special PI Issue of Black Cat Mystery Magazine. I owe a great debt to all three of those editors, because (as I realize now) that kind of story is always interesting to write; I'd just never before gotten around to trying it.


July


- I'm repeating myself here, but for the second year in a row, most of my original stories published were longer than what I've usually written. I've tried to put a reason to that, and I don't think there is one. The storylines that pop into my head recently just seem to take longer to tell.

- In 2023, as in the previous year, I had three stories appear in Alfred Hitchcock's Mystery Magazine. I was fortunate there, because that doesn't happen to me often. Over the years my AHMM stories have usually been, alas, spaced much farther apart. Two of those three this year were installments in a series. 

- Not that it matters, but since we're talking about statistics, about a fourth of my published stories this year were installments from four different mystery series. Those series feature (1) Sheriff Ray Douglas, (2) PI Tom Langford, (3) Angela Potts & Chunky Jones, and (4) Fran & Lucy Valentine. The rest of my     2023 stories were standalones. 

- Around two-thirds of my stories were in third-person POV, none were present tense, and none were set outside the U.S. And, as it turns out, only two of my stories this year were published outside the U.S.

- Three of my anthology publications in 2023 were in music-themed anthologies. In all, I think I've now published seven stories in anthos with music themes (four of those were edited by Josh Pachter), and several more have been accepted and are upcoming. Not sure why that topic has become so popular in recent years, but I admit those stories are always fun to write, and to read. (How could they not be?--For each story, you have a specific song in your head the whole time you're writing it.)

- I think about two-thirds of my this-year's stories could be called lighthearted instead of gritty. Not necessarily funny, but they didn't take themselves too seriously. Violencewise, most would probably carry the literary equivalent of a PG-13 rating, and some were PG.

- Almost three-quarters of this year's stories were set here in the South. Part of that is probably laziness. Not only am I more comfortable writing about locations I'm familiar with, they also require less research. Another part of it is that--as I mentioned--I didn't have as many Westerns published this year as I normally do. 

One thing I haven't said, here: Every magazine I mentioned also rejected at least one of my stories this year. Sad but true.


December


What have you noticed about the stories you've published, or submitted, or written, in 2023? Is the structure, content, genre, etc., the same as, or similar to, what you've done in the past? Any experimentation or big changes? Have you tried any new or different markets? Any success there? Please let me know, in the comments section.

Meanwhile, I hope all of you had a great Christmas, and I wish everyone a happy and successful new year, lifewise and writingwise. 

See you next Saturday . . . which IS next year.





34 comments:

  1. Wow!
    Edward Lodi

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Edward. Thank you--but (again) what I didn't talk about was my rejections, which were many. The great thing about this "job" is that--at least in my mind--one acceptance allows me to forget all the rejections that came before it. (Probably a good example of speculative fiction . . .)

      Delete
  2. Congratulations on another great year, John — and thanks for the shoutout! I always know that, when I invite you to submit to one of my anthologies, I'm going to get a terrific story that fits the book's parameters exactly and is delivered ahead of deadline, which is every editor's dream!....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Josh, you're too kind. The good thing about submitting to one of your anthologies is that your editing always makes my stories (anyone's stories) better than before. Much appreciated!

      Delete
  3. You set the standard high, John. Just keeping track of them all is an accomplishment. I hope 2024 is even better. --Susan Oleksiw

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Susan. As for keeping track, the real effort is in tracking submissions--what went where, how long ago, etc.--but you know all about that. Not a fun part of the job.

      I hope your 2024's a good one, too. Thank you as always.

      Delete
  4. Congratulations on another good year, John, and thanks for all your stories that I've had the good fortune to publish.

    My writing productivity this past year is nowhere near my peak productivity in 2009, but it is better than either of the past two years, and editing continues to occupy a fair bit of my time. I'll write my own yearly wrap-up in my next SleuthSayers post, and it will interesting (to me, at least) to see how I've done compared to previous years.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Michael, thank you for publishing them. It's always a pleasure and honor to be in your anthologies and magazines.

      I'll never know how you manage to write so many great stories while doing all the other writing tasks/jobs that you do. Your projects are always outstanding, and you've taught me a lot over the years. Looking forward to seeing (and being inspired by) your year-in-review!

      Delete
  5. Fantastic, John, and great productivity. As you could probably tell from my last blog post, this was not a highly productive year for me, but I did get a little done. May 2024 be (even) better for all of us!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Eve, you'll probably be an even better writer, after all you've been through this year. As I think I've told you before, yours is one of the names I always thought of anytime I submitted a story to AHMM, because I'd seen so many of yours in that magazine. Yes, have a great 2024!

      Delete
  6. Those are some impressive stats, John! I love that you sat down and analyzed themes, structure, craft etc in your stories that sold…it seems like a good practice for all writers to do at the end of the year. What was successful and what wasn’t? My stories ran the gamut this year, but I’m excited to have written 8 significant pieces and sold 5. What kinds of stories did you most enjoy writing?
    —Ashley-Ruth M. Bernier

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Ashley-Ruth--it's always good to hear from you, and I'm certainly getting used to seeing your name in publications lately!

      As for your question, the stories I most enjoy writing are the mysteries--probably because that's what I read most of the time. Also, though, anything that has a lot of humor is fun to write. (Humorous mysteries are the best!) And here's something else that occurred to me awhile back: the stories that are the most fun to write are almost always the easiest to get published. I guess that shouldn't be surprising.

      Thanks again!

      Delete
  7. I don't even know how you keep track, let alone turn out story after story of pure gold. Good year for you!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's so kind of you, Kaye. As I mentioned, keeping track of publications is easy--just write 'em down when they happen--but keeping up with submissions can be daunting. I try to be really careful about that, because when you write and send out a lot of stories to a lot of different places you HAVE to be careful. It's a juggling act, but it's fun too, in a weird kind of way.

      Keep up the good work--I'm looking forward to several of your projects, and one in particular!

      Delete
  8. And I thought I had a banner year with 24 stories, wow, you're giving me a kick in the shins, John! That is amazing. About "things I noticed". I'm relying a bit more on recurrent characters too. They really help me get in a mood, more than the standalone. I'm like: I feel I want to write a retro noir now, let's spend some time with Tom Keegan in San Francisco in 1950....

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yep, I know the feeling. There's just something about those series stories. For one thing, you're already familiar with the characters--and if this is your third or fourth or fifth, etc., story, readers have become familiar with them as well. Because of that, you sometimes don't have to spend as much time introducing/describing the characters, and can get right into the plot. It's just a more comfortable writing experience, or at least it can be. On the other hand, anything gets boring after awhile, and standalone stories can provide a needed break. They can allow you to try things you might not have done before. All kinds of things to consider, there.

      Thanks so much for your thoughts--and good luck with whatever story you try next. Twenty-four stories in a year is good, anytime.

      Delete
  9. Congratulations on another successful year. I'll try to control my jealousy! But you inspire me to keep plugging away!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Bob! No need to be jealous--I seem to be seeing your name everywhere lately, and I'm proud anytime I'm alongside you in a Table of Contents. There've been a lot of those, over the years.

      Keep writing the great stories. And thanks as always for coming to SleuthSayers!

      Delete
  10. Wow, John. You had more stories published this year than I've had published at all! Good for you! And happy new year!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Barb, the difference is that you--like Michael, Josh, etc.--have a lot more going on, writingwise, than I do. I can't imagine all the editing projects y'all do, and do WELL, and you STILL find the time to write award-winning work. All I do is write stories, and maybe mow the yard when it needs it. And by the way, you--and Michael and Josh, etc.--are the reason a lot of my stories got published this year.

      Happy new year to you too!

      Delete
  11. Congratulations on another great year, John. 57 stories...wow. That's as many stories as I've sold in my entire writing life. I love your annual reports because they encourage me to look more objectively at my own work.

    You're writing more PI stories, and I find that I'm writing fewer. The solution thing gives me trouble and I write many stories from the "bad guy" POV. A lot of those bad protagonists tend to be female, too. I don't know why that is, maybe because I worked with so many strong and intelligent women when I did theater. And because of my wife.

    I wrote 14 stories this year and had 10 (not all from that 14) published. Only four were PI stories and two others were police procedural...sort of. All the others concentrated on the "villain," usually a woman, getting even.

    Right now, nine stories are under submission (1 cop and 1 PI, 5 concentrating on the bad guy, 3 of them women), four are set for publication in the next year or so, and three are in early development, a euphemism for "a hot mess."

    My biggest challenge is finding new markets, which you also generously supply.

    Have a happy and healthy new year.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Steve! Thank you so much.

      Your stats are interesting. For one thing, it sounds as if you're writing ONLY crime fiction, right? No other or cross-genres. And I like it that you're writing a lot of stories from the bad guy's POV--that's always fun. As for PI stories, hey, I didn't even start writing those until a few years ago, and then only for by-invitation anthologies, at that time. I did find that I like those, though, and now I seem to be considering those stories a lot more often. And strong women are great protagonists--I've done that a lot.

      YES, the challenge for all of us is finding new markets. I rely a lot on the Short Mystery Fiction list to find those, and I also wind up googling "short fiction markets" pretty regularly. One of the best recent markets--Storia--sort of fell into my lap because I and several others (Josh, Stacy Woodson, and Bill McCormick) were contacted out of the blue about it earlier this year, but I've probably missed out on others I never ever heard about.

      Good luck to you on those stories that you currently have out--please keep me posted!

      Delete
    2. Yeah, SMFS is priceless, especially since Joseph Walker updates the market list every few months now. I've found a few possibilities there. And most of my stuff is crime, but I've sold a couple of supernatural and romance stories here and there. I have a supernatural (ghost) story making the rounds right now. I've never tried a western. Maybe someday...

      Delete
    3. Steve, I believe we're the same age, and I think one reason I love westerns so much is that I grew up watching so many of them on primetime TV when I was a kid. (It helps if you never grew up.)

      Delete
  12. Sigh. Kidding aside, John, I can marvel without envy (even kvell about my friend the fabulous Floyd), because we're so very apples and oranges: your prolific output and my occasional pop. I had two stories in AHMM this year (though the IRS took its cut for those in 2021 and 2022 respectively) and three flash stories in Yellow Mama (no pay but great company), as well as six poems in Yellow Mama over the course of the year. I've ended the year with a promising conversation with the guy at Storia, so fingers crossed for 2024.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Liz, you are too kind. And by the way, two stories in AHMM is great, and you've had continued success with Yellow Mama for years, right?--I've never even tried sending them a story. And if I sent them a poem they'd probably laugh so hard they couldn't get any work done the rest of the day. My poems aren't exactly contemporary, and they certainly aren't enlightening or inspirational. Enough said.

      Hope all goes well at Storia. I've been really satisfied with them so far.

      Delete
  13. Amazing, John. You never cease to impress me, managing both high output and high quality.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Leigh, that's so kind of you! All I'm sure of is that I do send out a good many stories. After that, I just sit back and hope for good results. I've been fortunate to get a lot of yeses, but I also get a lot of no-thank-yous. Wish I knew the secret to all this.

      Hope you're doing well, and I wish you a wonderful New Year!

      Delete
  14. Always impressive to see sales to AHMM & EQMM - tried to crack it half a dozen times, but without success. even though Mat Coward keeps telling me to submit to them. I've never been 'hungry enough' to try and go fully professional with my writing, but maybe in the coming year or so, things will be a little different :)

    As for Crimeucopia? Some call us a 'magazine', even though we consider ourselves an Anthology series (ISBNs I can handle, ISSNs are a different thing). It is what it is. Bound to come to an end eventually, but until then.... :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Coward is right, John--keep trying. I've never figured out what kinds of stories AHMM and EQMM like best, so I just write as good a story as I can and send it in and see what happens. Michael Bracken and I have talked about this a lot, and what we finally agreed on is that EQMM *seems* to like stories that are really "different" in some way. And that AHMM is *sometimes* more likely than EQMM to accept cross-genre stories: westerns, humor, speculative elements, etc. Who knows?

      Thanks for mentioning Crimeucopia. I think some consider it a magazine because it's been a regular occurrence for the past few years. But I'm glad you clarified it: it is indeed an anthology. I love it, too, and I hope you'll keep 'em comin'.

      Delete
  15. Amazing work as always, John. I don't know how you do it!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Joe--but as I said to you the other day, YOU're the one whose name I'm seeing in just about every Table of Contents lately. Proud to know you--Keep on truckin'!

      Delete
  16. Amazing stats...and thank you for mentioning the rejections. Early-carrer folks like me really find it encouraging to know the major pro's get 'em too! My highlights? First AHMM, Mystery Magazine AND Black Cat Weekly this year. Plus maybe ten more rejections from EQMM and a couple others that really hurt. Right now, next year looks like more long stuff, but who knows? Again, John, thank you so much for the inspiration!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kathleen, how kind of you. I don't know about the "major pro" stuff, but I know I dern sure get my share of rejections. Every one of those magazines you mentioned have rejected my stories. Just keep trying 'em. When they reject a story, send them another. And send the rejected story someplace else. Don't ever just let them sit there at home collecting dust!

      Delete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>