21 November 2026

Seriesly Speaking


Some of you might already know that SleuthSayers began fifteen years ago, immediately following the end of its predecessor, the Criminal Brief mystery blog. Well, not that it matters, but it occurred to me this past week that if you count my every-Saturday blog columns at CB, today marks my 590th mystery-blog post. (My typing fingers get tired just thinking about it.) It also occurred to me that the posts I most enjoy writing are the ones where I offer highly biased and unscientific opinions about favorites. Favorites in several areas, but mostly about novels, short stories, movies, etc. And I like doing those because of what I usually learn from the responses to those posts. I have discovered, via our dear readers's comments, a wealth of great books and stories to read and great movies and TV shows to watch.

With that in mind, and since I have often posted in the past about what I think are the best novels, stories, and movies, I figured I'd do the same for the source of one of my MTW (Most Time-Wasting) activities: episodic series that can be streamed via services like Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, and others.

What I like about these series (if they're good) is that they give the viewer time to get deeply involved in the characters, settings, and so forth. And even though my very favorite series have been multi-season epics (see the list below), I also like the single-season "limited" series because they're like very long movies that can be binge-watched in half a dozen (or so) sittings. Also, their final episodes are big-bang finales that don't involve cliffhangers to entice you to watch subsequent seasons. (Let's hear it for instant gratification.)

For today's post, I'm focusing on favorite streamable mystery/crime series, which does not include shows like Rome, Deadwood, Lost, Game of Thrones, Mad Men, The Walking Dead, Band of Brothers, 1883, 1923, and Landman--all ten of which I thought were EXCELLENT. I'm also not including regular old-time network series like Hill Street Blues, Columbo, and NYPD Blue, or streaming series that I liked but haven't seen all the way to the end, like Slow Horses, Dexter, Sherlock, Sons of Anarchy, etc.

So, without further sermonizing or disclaimers, here are my ten picks for all-time best streamable crime series:

1. The Sopranos -- My absolute favorite. I think Tony Soprano was (along with Augustus McCrae) one of best fictional characters ever put on film, and the late James Gandolfini one of the best actors I've ever seen. 6 seasons, 86 episodes.

2. The Wire -- It's still hard for me to believe a dark, violent, mostly inner-city crime show could be this good. 5 seasons, 60 episodes.

3. Breaking Bad -- Not the very top of my list, but it's way up there. I saw this one after almost everyone I know had already watched it, and it lived up to its reputation. 5 seasons, 62 episodes.

4. Justified -- I figured this show's connection to Elmore Leonard would make it work--and it did. I grew to like one of its antagonists, Boyd Crowder, almost as much as I liked the hero. 6 seasons, 78 episodes. 

5. True Detective -- Great series, but I thought its first season was by far the best. 4 seasons, 30 episodes.

6. Better Call Saul -- In my opinion, almost as good as Breaking Bad, and at times better. 6 seasons, 78 episodes.

7. Boardwalk Empire -- One of the two historical crime shows in this list. Great story, unlikely hero. 6 seasons, 56 episodes.

8. Ozark -- An extremely different crime series, in an extremely different setting. 4 seasons, 44 episodes.

9. Fargo -- How often do you find an excellent movie and an excellent series with the same name? (Except for M*A*S*H). I thought the first two seasons of Fargo were the best, but it was outstanding throughout. 5 seasons, 51 episodes.

10. Peaky Blinders -- The second of the two historicals. I don't always go for dark and grimy and brooding, but boy it sure worked here. 6 seasons, 36 episodes.

NOTE: Goliath almost made my top ten, mostly because of Billy Bob, and I would probably have also included Reacher in the list if it had stopped after one season. I thought Reacher's second season was terrible and the third and fourth were lukewarm. (Feel free to disagree.)


How about you? Which crime series is your favorite? Which others are close? And while we're at it, which series of any genre did you enjoy the most?

Always remember, crime writers, that watching these series is a form of research. Maybe we should start claiming streaming-service subscription fees as tax-deductible expenses . . .

There's gotta be a story in that.


Happy Thanksgiving, everyone!

16 comments:

  1. John, I've seen only two on your list (no television), but I liked both, Justified and True Detective (which has a fascinating single-camera chase scene). I also liked Goliath, although the 3rd season wasn't as good as the others.

    Going back to Justified, I too found my self wanting Boyd to get right with the universe. The scene with the knife game was genius and terrifying, but what I liked best was the little security guard (maybe Wendell Robinson?) who, under torture, refused to betray others. That's one of the best plot lines ever.

    There was a series possibly in the mid 1990s called Murder One. I don't recall the lead actor's name. He agreed to star in the show but insisted the program terminate after one season, and it was one terrific legal drama. He kept his word but the show runners didn't. They went for a second season without that actor, and it was a shadow of season one.

    Footnote for researchers: I tried to look up another series. My results were for naught, When I began asking questions, I discovered TV Guide apparently hasn't archived their earlier magazines. There's a private attempt to catalogue TV Guide articles, but it's haphazard, incomplete, and dubiously searchable. Have I missed something? Thus far, I've found no alternative. Why is it I, a guy without a television, who's concerned we're losing a historical resource documenting a pasttime that consumed such a huge proportion of viewers' lives?

    John, thank you and congratulations as you near your 600th post.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. No TV?? Just another reason I admire you, Leigh. But tell the truth: Don't you watch some of those series on the computer . . . ?

      Oh man, I loved Justified. And that scene with the knife (it was an ice pick, right?) and the tablecloth--that's a classic. I haven't seen the followup series, supposedly featuring Raylan in Detroit, but (good reminder!) I'm gonna check it out.

      I remember Murder One, but not in detail. I too have heard that its season one was exceptional but that it faltered afterward.

      I like your footnote. Interesting!! I really think you should take on that task of finding and revealing those missing articles.

      Thank you as always, Leigh. And hey, you've written more of these posts than I have! Take care.

      Delete
  2. To this I would add WISEGUY. And, perhaps stretching things beyond your original intent, ROCKY AND BULLWINKLE.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ha! That's two of 'em that I remember (now). Yes, Wiseguy was a good one!

      Thanks, Jerry.

      Delete
  3. Melodie Campbell21 November, 2026 10:55

    Isn't this interesting, John! I'm always interested to see how men and women think differently, when it comes to books and shows I found most of those shows too male-centric and violent (even though I do write about the mob myself!) At the top of my list would be the Brit, Aussie/New Zealand and Italian shows - Montalbano at the very top, then Morse, Brokenwood, Ludwig.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're right, Melodie--I certainly think my wife I would differ greatly on a list like this one. And you're also right (he said, with a guilty look) that every one of my ten picks were pretty violent. If we get away from the crime genre though, I'm a little more enlightened in my viewing. (I shouldn't reveal this, but Love Actually, Sense and Sensibility, and Somewhere in Time are among my favorite movies. Oh my, did I really say that?)

      I promise you this: I will check out the four series you mentioned--especially Montalbano. Thanks!

      Delete
    2. Jim Guigli www.jimguigliauthor.com21 November, 2026 12:13

      My wife and I love Montalbano. After much effort we have collected all the episodes on disk and watch the whole series every summer.

      Delete
    3. Good for you, Jim! I too like to find the series I really love on DVD and rewatch them from time to time. I must find and watch Montalbano.

      My wife and I faithfully watched Downton Abbey when it was first broadcast long ago. I thought I would hate it, and wound up looking forward to every episode. I've been thinking of getting that series on DVD.

      I've now watched Deadwood (only 3 seasons) several times now, start to finish. Alas, my wife is NOT fond of that one.

      Delete
  4. The reference to Criminal Briefs brings back a lot of memories, most of which are otherwise "off topic" for today's piece but I thought I would wander off today's path just a bit to reference that James Lincoln Warren, who founded Criminal Briefs, passed away on Halloween of this year.

    I met James for the first time at the Ellery Queen Mystery Magazine annual pre-Edgars cocktail party in 2008. I was unpublished at the time, but my first Ellery Queen pastiche, "The Book Case," had been accepted by EQMM and I had scored an invite to the cocktail party. During the party I found myself visiting with Steven Steinbock when James came up and immediately button-holed Steve with an offer to participate in a new blog that James was about to start -- Criminal Briefs. As James explained, his idea was that blogs were too difficult for one person to maintain, but this problem would be solved by employing a cast of characters, each of whom would be in charge of one day per week. I was sort of like a third thumb during this discussion since I was unpublished and known to no one. But I listened with interest and enthusiastically followed Criminal Briefs, appeared several times as a guest contributor and got to know James well over the years when we would visit at subsequent cocktail parties and at Bouchercon gatherings. He was always encouraging and a couple times asked me if I would like to be included as a Criminal Briefs regular. I always declined, thinking I would have a hard time committing to a weekly schedule.

    After I retired I did join SleuthSayers as a regular for several years and my opening piece credited James with having sort of "found me." I know that James could be a strict task master -- he knew what he wanted Criminal Briefs to look like and he enforced that vision. In founding Criminal Briefs (the archives of which are still available on line) James set the stage for SleuthSayers. He will be missed.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey, Dale. Yes, any mention of CB does bring back a lot of memories.

      I first met JLW in 2008 also, at the Baltimore Bouchercon in October of that year. I had signed on at Criminal Brief not long before that. He WAS a strict taskmaster, but also (as you said) always encouraging and generous. He will indeed be missed.

      Delete
  5. Putting the Justified picture right up there was guaranteed to make me read the post :) - we all have our top shows. I would put Saul above Breaking Bad, that I just couldn't get into. I would sneak "Broadchurch" in there ...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Martine, there was just something special about Justified--probably that the main character was SO different from most, right? I thoroughly enjoyed it.

      I honestly hadn't intended to get started on Better Call Saul--it had already aired so many seasons and episodes, I didn't want to commit that kind of time to what I considered a "spinoff" series. Then I got talked into it, and loved it. As for Broadchurch, I've heard from several folks that I should watch that--thank you for the recommendation!

      Delete
  6. Hi John! If you liked Peaky Blinders, you'll also love Ripper Street. Funny, I'm not sure why, but I haven't watched many of the others. And I agree with Martine about Broadchurch. A lot of what we watch is on BritBox, come to think of it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Ripper Street, huh? And y'all think *I* like the violent shows! Seriously, I'll check it out--I think I've heard of it, but I've heard no details.

      As for bloodcurdling screams and such, I think the Call the Midwife episodes my wife has been watching has more of those than Widow's Bay did, and WB is a horror show. (Good, though!)

      And sure enough, Bobbi, I'll find Broadchurch. Thanks!

      Delete
  7. Streamed The Sopranos, Breaking Bad, Fargo, and *some* of Peaky Blinders. Most recently, I've been streaming horror series -- rewatching Tales From The Crypt and the series version of Creepshow. I don't have *any* conscious favorites when it comes to streaming, just what occurs to me at the moment.

    Fantastic going on your 590th post, only 10 more until 600!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hey Justin! Peaky Blinders can be addictive, I bet you'll finish that one at some point. And yep, Creepshow (originally featuring Stephen King stories, I guess it still does) was fun. Thanks for the thoughts!

      I suspect there'll be a big parade and celebration when I reach 600 posts--be sure to listen for the crowd noise and music . . .

      Delete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>