14 May 2026

All About the Atmosphere


We read and we write mysteries here at SleuthSayers (as well as other genres) for a variety of reasons, for the skill, the plots, the dialog, the puzzle, but sometimes what we're really interested in is the atmosphere. That fits our mood. Some of my favorites:

Maigret (Georges Simenon) - Paris; places like the Gai Moulon or the Liberty Bar, where no one who isn't a criminal or a policeman should dream of going; Mme. Maigret with her excellent cuisine; the team, detectives Lucas, Janvier, Lapointe, and Torrence; Maigret's pipe, his taste for beer and cognac, his intuition, and his occasional mercy to criminals...  Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful...

NOTE:  The 1960s British series Maigret, starring Rupert Davies, is available on YouTube. "Davies' portrayal won two of the highest accolades: his versions were dubbed into French and played across the Channel; and Simenon himself said of Davies "At last, I have found the perfect Maigret!" (LINK)

Nero Wolfe (Rex Stout) - The household, of course.  The voice of Archie Goodwin, the strict schedule, the orchids upstairs, the gourmet meals of Fritz (although I must confess I have the Nero Wolfe Cookbook, and I didn't like most of the recipes.  I fear they're better on the page than off it. I for one do not want apricot preserves in my omelet.).  Also the supporting team, especially Saul Panzer and Fred Durkin. Orrie Cather can stuff himself. 

Bernie Gunther (Philip Kerr) - Dark, atmospheric, scary, but... depending on the day and the mood...

Mma Ramotswe (Andrew McCall Smith) - It's the rhythm of the voice, the feel of the heat of the day, the smell of cows, the preciousness of rain, the customs, the courtesies, the myths, the secrets, the witchcraft, the traditions.  And the supporting team, her secretary and later assistant Mma Makutsi, her husband Mr JLB Matekoni, Mma Silvia Potokwani of the orphan farm, her stepchildren Motholeli and Puso, and Gabarone, Botswana itself.  As it says at the end of the first book, 

Africa Africa Africa Africa Africa

Africa Africa Africa Africa

Africa Africa Africa

Africa Africa

Africa

Spenser (Robert Parker) - To be honest, mostly for Hawk and the banter between the two of them. What drives me crazy is Susan and her perpetual wonder at the Hawk/Spenser friendship and total trust. Honey, I have girlfriends who if one of us called the other in the middle of the night, would drop everything to help, no matter what, and bring anything / everything needed, whether it's money, a bottle, a shovel or all three and more...  Why Parker wrote a woman who apparently has no women friends I don't know.

Dame Frevisse (Margaret Frazer) - First of all, it's the real Middle Ages.  Second, I really like Dame Frevisse, who is prickly, dedicated, and knows her stuff. She also sometimes gets fed up with her fellow sisters, and who wouldn't get fed up with Dame Alys? Related to Chaucer, her cousin is Alice Chaucer, Duchess of Suffolk, which gives Dame Frevisse her access to the nobility, and often gets her mixed up in their problems, mysteries, and murders. And, as I've said many a time, the motive in The Servant's Tale - well, I only wish I'd thought of it first.

Cadfael (Ellis Peters) - My second favorite medieval religious.  My favorite of the books is An Excellent Mystery.  

Brunetti (Donna Leon) - Venice. Venice. Venice. Venice. Venice.  I went to Venice and I fell in love with it the way a teenager falls in love with that sexy guy who is the LAST person she should ever be with and yes, she knows it, but she can't stop, can't stop, she's in madly, deeply, hopelessly, recklessly...  Brunetti gives me access from afar, full of its scents and sounds, especially the water lapping everywhere...  

Venice, by Eve Fisher:

Miss Marple (Agatha Christie) – I love her. Period. I hope to be her in my increasing old age, only with more profanity and sarcasm. 

Sherlock Holmes (Conan Doyle) – Straight back to my childhood.  

And thank you, Janice Law, for the amazing Francis Bacon series!  

  • Fires of London (2012)
  • The Prisoner of the Riviera (2013)
  • Moon Over Tangier (2014)
  • Nights in Berlin (2016)
  • Afternoons in Paris (2017)
  • Mornings in London (2017)

Somedays, there's just nothing like a seedy, louche adventurer with a nanny and a lot of bad habits to get you through the day...

Other notes:

Marion Halcome (Wilkie Collins, The Woman in White), who is the real sleuth, the real heroine. And she's up against Count Fosco, an Italian of uncertain past, huge girth, strong personality, and incredibly dangerous. "This in two words: He looks like a man who could tame anything. If he had married a tigress, instead of a woman, he would have tamed the tigress. If he had married me, I should have made his cigarettes, as his wife does—I should have held my tongue when he looked at me, as she holds hers." (Don't worry, he never manages to tame Marion. In fact, he falls in love with her, but that doesn't stop him from being excessively dangerous.) Plus I love the different voices that Collins uses to tell the tale, such as the most useless person ever to take fictional breath, Frederick Fairlie:  

"It is the grand misfortune of my life that nobody will let me alone.  Why—I ask everybody—why worry me? Nobody answers that question, and nobody lets me alone. Relatives, friends, and strangers all combine to annoy me. What have I done? I ask myself, I ask my servant, Louis, fifty times a day—what have I done? Neither of us can tell. Most extraordinary!"

I consider this the best of Collins, and I have reread it many times, with great pleasure.  

Also, thank you, Elizabeth Zelvin for clueing me in to Abbi Waxman's One Death at a Time!  The most truly Hollywood novel I've ever read.  (Let's face facts, Chandler romanticized L.A. even if it was a dark romanticism.)  

Which reminds me, I also want to see Lodge 49 again.  



15 comments:

  1. Melodie Campbell14 May, 2026 09:30

    What is Lodge 49?? You can't stop there, Eve! Adding a few more names to my list, thanks to you. And I'm going to revisit others, like A Woman in White.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Melodie, Lodge 49 is a FANTASTIC (imho) TV series that was on for only 2 seasons, set around a mysterious Lodge (The Order of the Lynx) with a bat-shit crazy Southern California membership and wanna-bes (par for the course there). With an incredible cast, and some of the wildest walk-ons - Bruce Campbell, Cheech Marin, Paul Giamatti...
      Available on AMC+ and (for free) on Roku!

      Delete
  2. I grew up on the Spenser books and still love many aspects of them, but, yes, Susan is a problem, and becomes more and more of a problem as the books go on. She's essentially written as the ideal girlfriend--worshipfully devoted to her man, gorgeous, always available and eager for sex, and never too demanding of Spenser's time or attention. I really got tired of hearing about how tiny her bites are every time they had a meal. She's a more interesting and fully rounded character in the first half of the series (it's startling to go back to her first appearance in the second Spenser novel, GOD SAVE THE CHILD, where the first thing Spenser says about her is that she's striking but not beautiful). Parker got to the point, though, where he was putting out one Spenser a year like clockwork, and the formula was as rigid as in the Hardy Boy books. In those books, all Susan ever seems to do is have meals with Spenser where they talk endlessly about how perfect their relationship is.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, Susan is written that way, isn't she? The perfect girlfriend (thinking of the "Gone Girl" rant about the 'cool girl' - available here:
      https://www.reddit.com/r/FemaleDatingStrategy/comments/j0e1ky/cool_girl_monologue_by_gillian_flynn/
      Like I said, I read Spenser books for Hawk.

      Delete
  3. Thanks for the mention of my friend Francis Bacon- and nanny. You are quite right about the joys of atmosphere, especially Paris, Venice and Botswana with the Ladies' Detective agency.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks anonymous! I think I know who you are!

      Delete
  4. Jerry Sweeney14 May, 2026 10:54

    It's also available on Internet Archive.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Jerry Sweeney14 May, 2026 11:17

    Mayhap as a consequence of my addiction to television programs from Down Under, I found the Kerry Greenwood Corinna Chapman series, replete with recipes, addictive. Unfortunately, it was cut short after seven books, by the author's death. There were Amazon critics who found it wanting, they are wrong. I wish she had started it earlier.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Eve, so glad you loved One Death At A Time. Apricot preserves, or better, fig preserves, just a soupçon, are quite good on foie gras, not on omelet. I love Corinna Chapman too. It's a muffin shop series with recipes, but it would be as misleading to call it cozy as the Anglican vicar Merrily Watkins paranormal (also a misleading term) series set in a picturesque village on the Welsh border. I'm also fond of P.F. Chisholm's Sir Robert Carey books, set on the Scottish Borders and a bit in Elizabethan England, and Dorothy Dunnett's Crawford of Lymond, Scotland and England, France, Russia, and other places dripping with atmosphere a generation earlier. I question only Dunnett's take on the Ottoman Turks, especially the harem, at least since I started writing about it myself.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I never liked Dunnett's Lymond series, because I couldn't warm up to Lymond. On the other hand, I LOVE her "King Hereafter" about Macbeth. Wow! I also liked the Hamish Macbeth books, but not the TV series.

      Delete
    2. King Hereafter was a tour de force but too painful for me. The guy couldn't catch a break. Same reason I'm not a noir fan. And the ending still haunts me decades later. Also forgot to say I liked the Venice poem too—well done!

      Delete
  7. Eve, I've read and enjoyed most of these. I read Women in White as a kid without realizing its significance in the mystery world. One of my favorites has been Ellis Peters, and I found myself comparing her medieval environment with that of British historical writer, Edward Marston. The difference was striking. Although I preferred Peter's characterizations and often her plots, Marston's physical atmospheres rang more authentic– the dirt and grit, the stench of ever-present feces, the pain and hopelessness of disease, a far cry from the antiseptic world Cadfael inhabits. Pity the Connecticut Yankee…

    ReplyDelete
  8. I'll have to check out Marston - and I'm glad you liked "Venice".

    ReplyDelete
  9. I haven't read One Death at a Time, either - but now I will!

    ReplyDelete

Welcome. Please feel free to comment.

Our corporate secretary is notoriously lax when it comes to comments trapped in the spam folder. It may take Velma a few days to notice, usually after digging in a bottom drawer for a packet of seamed hose, a .38, her flask, or a cigarette.

She’s also sarcastically flip-lipped, but where else can a P.I. find a gal who can wield a candlestick phone, a typewriter, and a gat all at the same time? So bear with us, we value your comment. Once she finishes her Fatima Long Gold.

You can format HTML codes of <b>bold</b>, <i>italics</i>, and links: <a href="https://about.me/SleuthSayers">SleuthSayers</a>